6.37pm
3 May 2024
As someone with autism/ADHD/OCD, I love listing my favorite musician’s most well known songs and making a setlist out of it. It just helps me relax and remove all of my stress. However, there are three musicians I am having some trouble with, because they have SO MANY hit songs that its hard to narrow them down. And one of them is the Beatles.
Unlike the others, all of the data for the Beatles’ hits (Spotify, YouTube, setlist.fm, Billboard, chartmasters, single sales, album sales, cultural significance, etc.) is inconsistent. For example, take Spotify stats from kworb.net., The Fool On The Hill is like 89 most played, but is one of the most covered Beatles songs ever by far (14th on secondhandsongs.com). And that’s just one song.
So I want to make a definitive list aggregating and taking into account all of the aforementioned data but I don’t think of capable of doing it alone. So I want to ask the help of the dedicated fans on this forum. And I chose 50 songs because it’s a nice big even number, and I needed to limit it to one set amount. So what are the 50 most famous Beatles songs?
11.02pm
26 January 2017
This is an interesting exercise, because like you said Fool On the Hill doesn't have very impressive numbers on Spotify, but is very frequently covered. There are so many objective metrics from so many different ages that you could use to rank them. I think the best way would be through tiers.
Im busy right now so I will fill this out with songs later, but I think the tiers would look something like this.
Ubiquitous Classics
Undisputed Masterpieces
Mega Hits
Help !
Ob La Di (don't know the name for this tier but it is basically enormously popular songs that for one reason or another aren't universally known or loved.)
Ob La Di Ob La Da
With A Little Help From My Friends
Octopus Garden
Big Singles and Beloved album tracks.
You've Got To Hide Your Love Away
Sgt Pepper 's Lonely Hearts Club Band
----- This is 50. Im gonna keep filling out the tiers.
Ive Just Seen A Face
Cult classics
- endless list if Im not capped at 50 the fun really starts here
These would be my tiers, Im gonna try to try to fill out later today.
Edit: im slowly filling it out, I did the first few tiers and am at 39 songs. Gonna be hard to make cuts going forward because most of my favorite songs are in these last 2 tiers. let me know if you disagree with the tier selection, order, and songs chosen.
Edit 2 - Im up to 50 and I feel like I got there pretty easily. Monstrous catalog, its a joke.
The following people thank sir walter raleigh for this post:
sigh butterfly, Rube"The pump don't work cause the vandals took the handles!"
-Bob Dylan, Subterranean Homesick Blues
"We could ride and surf together while our love would grow"
-Brian Wilson, Surfer Girl
5.34am
11 June 2015
I like what you did there Sir! For grins, here are the Top 50 songs from each of the 3 Forum Polls. Perhaps our resident statistician @Jules can help us make sense of all this data. Btw- even though a core of 20 forum members participated in all 3 polls, the #1 song is different in each one.
Also, I believe we were allowed to vote for the AB Medley as well as each separate element. @Ahhh Girl may be able to confirm this.
2015 (ULTIMATE)
050. I’m So Tired
049. Got To Get You Into My Life
048. Taxman
047. She Said She Said
046. She Loves You
044. Blackbird
043. Nowhere Man
042. Sgt. Pepper ‘s Lonely Hearts Club Band
041. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds
040. Hey Bulldog
039. Being For The Benefit Of Mr Kite !
038. Twist And Shout
037. I Feel Fine
036. Paperback Writer
035. Here There And Everywhere
034. Get Back
033. Back In The USSR
031. Helter Skelter
030. Come Together
028. A Hard Day’s Night
027. Revolution
026. I’m Only Sleeping
025. I Am The Walrus
024. For No One
023. Yesterday
022. Rain
021. Day Tripper
020. All My Loving
019. Across The Universe
018. Ticket To Ride
017. Penny Lane
016. Help !
015. Tomorrow Never Knows
013. Norwegian Wood
012. Let It Be
011. The End
010. Because
009. Eleanor Rigby
008. Dear Prudence
007. In My Life
006. Hey Jude
005. Here Comes The Sun
004. While My Guitar Gently Weeps
003. Something
002. Strawberry Fields Forever
001. A Day In The Life
2015 (CANON)
049 With A Little Help From My Friends
048 I’m Only Sleeping
047 Please Please Me
046 She Came In Through The Bathroom Window
045 Two of Us
044 Yesterday
043 Come Together
042 Helter Skelter
040 Paperback Writer
039 Sgt. Pepper ‘s Lonely Hearts Club Band
037 Taxman
036 Feel Fine
035 Girl
034 Hey Jude
033 Sgt. Pepper ‘s Lonely Hearts Club Band (Reprise)
032 Because
031 For No One
030 Here, There And Everywhere
029 She Loves You
028 You’ve Got To Hide Your Love Away
027 Hey Bulldog
026 You Never Give Me Your Money
025 Twist And Shout
024 Rain
023 Revolution
022 Nowhere Man
020 Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds
019 Dear Prudence
017 A Hard Day’s Night
016 Penny Lane
015 Day Tripper
014 Help !
012 Ticket To Ride
011 Eleanor Rigby
010 The End
009 Norwegian Wood (This Bird Has Flown)
008 I Am The Walrus
007 Something
006 Abbey Road Medley
005 While My Guitar Gently Weeps
004 In My Life
2018 (CANON)
050 Lovely Rita
049 Hey Jude
048 Got To Get You Into My Life
047 I’m So Tired
046 You Never Give Me Your Money
045 Eleanor Rigby
044 Come Together
043 Lady Madonna
042 Get Back [album version]
041 You’ve Got To Hide Your Love Away
040 Back In The USSR
039 Sgt. Pepper ‘s Lonely Hearts Club Band (Reprise)
035 Get Back [single version]
034 Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds
033 Girl
032 Here, There And Everywhere
030 With A Little Help From My Friends
029 Sgt. Pepper ‘s Lonely Hearts Club Band
028 Something
025 Nowhere Man
024 For No One
023 Day Tripper
022 Taxman
021 Paperback Writer
020 Dear Prudence
019 Penny Lane
018 Help !
017 The End
016 A Hard Day’s Night
015 In My Life
014 Twist And Shout
013 Helter Skelter
012 Revolution
010 Hey Bulldog
008 Ticket To Ride
007 Rain
006 Norwegian Wood
005 While My Guitar Gently Weeps
004 Abbey Road Medley
001 I Am The Walrus
The following people thank sigh butterfly for this post:
RubeYou and I have memories
Longer than the road that stretches out ahead
1 Guest(s)