Log In
Register
11.32am
14 March 2016
Offline
I like this thread and I do read all the different ideas on here because I like hearing other’s ideas
I hope the new release has some cool gems on it because we already have the single versions of PL/SFF and both versions this album on CD. Behind the scenes on SPLHCB and SFF/PL would be cool as a bonus disc since they were in the same recording time frame.
The following people thank Reklo87 for this post:
SgtPeppersBulldog"No Beatles collection is too big or age restricted!"
5.16pm
Reviewers
Moderators
1 May 2011
Offline 
We also wouldn’t have some of the tracks that ended up on the album as the concept changed entirely and different songs would been recorded. The idea is so badly flawed from every angle it would scream of Apple just being piss poor lazy.
"I told you everything I could about me, Told you everything I could" ('Before Believing' - Emmylou Harris)
12.45pm
12 March 2017
Offline
Hello, I’m new here, I would like to say my opinion, I think the idea to add those songs to the ‘Sgt. Pepper ‘ album is nice. Because is a new experience how would it have been in the past. But I have something against,I think Sgt. Pepper ‘s Lonely Hearts Club Band it’s a band from a parallel universe, so I think in that universe Penny Lane doesn’t exists and Strawberry Field too, so it doesn’t make sense that they are there. Sorry for my english, I’m a foreigner. Long live The Beatles!
The following people thank El Submarino Amarillo for this post:
Ahhh Girl, William Shears Campbell, William Shears Campbell, William Shears Campbell, TheWalrusWasBrian, Hendrick992.08pm
26 January 2017
Offline I like my albums to have 5,8,12 or 14 songs on personally, so I would take off 2 and add 3.
I would take off Fixing A Hole and Lovely Rita , and I would add on All You Need Is Love (written soon after the release but I feel it fits the album), SFF, and Penny Lane .
So my track list would be:
Side 1
1. Sgt Pepper ‘s Lonely Hearts Club Band
2. With A Little Help From My Friends
3. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds
5. Penny Lane
Side 2
9. Being For The Benefit Of Mr Kite
10. Getting Better
13. Sgt Pepper ‘s Lonely Hearts Club Band (Reprise)
I put Getting Better in side 2 because I thought it would need something to liven it up. Other changes would include reminding us more often that we are witnessing the band play, because I think that tails off in the original.
The following people thank QuarryMan for this post:
SgtPeppersBulldogI've been up on the mountain, and I've seen his wondrous grace,
I've sat there on the barstool and I've looked him in the face.
He seemed a little haggard, but it did not slow him down,
he was humming to the neon of the universal sound.
1.38pm
17 March 2017
Offline To me, if you subbed Penny Lane & Strawberry Fields onto Sgt. Pepper , you’d have to take two songs off of the album and make them singles. I would swap Penny Lane for When I’m Sixty-Four (Paul song for Paul song) as the A-side and Strawberry Fields for Good Morning Good Morning (John song for John song) as the B-side. Might have to do some slight rearranging of the song order to make it work, but either way, those two songs probably should have been on the album, and I think George Martin said he regretted not doing it that way.
2.10pm
5 February 2010
Offline meanmistermustard said
We also wouldn’t have some of the tracks that ended up on the album as the concept changed entirely and different songs would been recorded. The idea is so badly flawed from every angle it would scream of Apple just being piss poor lazy.
It would be one thing if we had some evidence (interviews, personal testimony, studio chatter, whatever) that they had a plan to include these two songs originally in some specific way. You know, maybe a quote from Paul somewhere saying, “Penny Lane was going to be the big opener on side two of the album,” or something like that.
At least then it would feel like there was a blueprint for the re-release.
But as it stands? Where are the “suits” even going to include these songs? They wouldn’t dare try to mess with the original track listing, I don’t think, but what’s the point in just tacking on two extra songs as “bonus tracks” at the end of the album?
Not a bit like Cagney.
3.54pm
26 January 2017
Offline meanmistermustard said
Certainly up to the end of ’65 they were endlessly on the go with albums, bbc shows, tours, movies etc but it was a bit more relaxed in ’66 when they had a few quieter months at the beginning of the year and at the end. Admittedly The Beatles lp was a double but for ’66 onwards they only released new 1 album a year (in the UK MMT was an EP and Yellow Submarine had only 4 new tracks all recorded earlier) and a collection of singles.Their schedule in ’63 and ’64 especially when they were conquering the UK and then the World is amazing. Its written so often that it can be taken for granted but go and have a look at how much running around without a breather they did. Bands nowadays bitch if they do a tour without 2 days off between gigs, The Beatles were travelling from city to city overnight for the next show often miles apart as it had all been so badly planned at times fitting in press appearances.
I recognise that this post is from 2013, @meanmrmustard , but if you think about it, they did at the very least record two albums per year with the exception of 1966.
1963 – PPM , WTB
1964 – AHDN , BFS
1965 – Help !, RS
1966 – Revolver
1967 – SPLHCB , MMT (The latter isn’t technically an album but has roughly the same amount of songs)
1968 – TWA (A double album so counting as 2, plus the singles)
1969 – LIB (Released the following year but almost entirely recorded in 1969), Abbey Road .
I've been up on the mountain, and I've seen his wondrous grace,
I've sat there on the barstool and I've looked him in the face.
He seemed a little haggard, but it did not slow him down,
he was humming to the neon of the universal sound.
5.14am
28 April 2020
Offline Thinking about this recently, that if Strawberry Fields Forever and Penny Lane hadn’t been released as a single, they would have been on the album and it is unlikely that Paul would have come up with the concept of Sgt Pepper !
Therefore, the two songs I’d remove are the two versions of the Sgt Pepper song but also add in ‘Only A Northern Song ‘….
SIDE 1
2. With A Little Help From My Friends
7. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds
SIDE 2
1. Penny Lane
2. For The Benefit Of Mr. Kite
3. When I’m 64
6. Lovely Rita
Without the concept, they may not have added the links between a few of the songs, so it would have just been an album of songs … and a really good album too!
The following people thank alittlebitolder for this post:
Rube9.58pm
10 August 2011
Offline This being the 55th anniversary of the album, there will be a new round of analyses.
McCartney has added bonus tracks to his albums, and this has enhanced them. (Nobody buys vinyl or CDs except for a small # of people).
Penny Lane and SFF should be added as bonus tracks.
a) As pointed out, they were meant for the album
b) There’s no limit to how many songs can be on an album now that people stream songs and albums
c) people who want to check out the Beatles by listening to their albums will miss out on all the singles that were never on the original albums.
So yes, add Hey Jude and Revolution (the raucous version) as bonus tracks to the White Album , I Want To Hold Your Hand to With the Beatles, etc…
The following people thank Into the Sky with Diamonds for this post:
Richard, Von Bontee, Rube"Into the Sky with Diamonds" (the Beatles and the Race to the Moon – a history)
11.05am
14 June 2016
Offline It didn’t happen, even if I thought it should have. Thus I’m okay keeping it that way. It is what it is.
The following people thank Timothy for this post:
Rube1.The Beatles 2.Sgt. Pepper 3.Abbey Road 4.Magical Mystery Tour 5.Rubber Soul 6.Revolver 7.Help! 8.Let It Be
9.A Hard Day’s Night 10.Please Please Me 11.Beatles For Sale 12.With The Beatles 13.Yellow Submarine
Most Avid John Fan 2020 and 2021: 
8.26pm
14 December 2009
Offline
Maybe I’m just set in my ways, but I think that both this masterful album, and the equally masterful 45, would be diminished by being combined. I like to imagine the single as a separate miniature version of the album.
I do, however, 
the idea of the Rubb/olver pair each being released as 16-song albums with Paperback writer/Rain and Day Tripper /We Can Work It Out included. And a “Beatles For Sale ” with I Feel Fine //She’s A Woman , for that matter.
The following people thank Von Bontee for this post:
RubePaul: Yeah well… first of all, we’re bringing out a ‘Stamp Out Detroit’ campaign.
9.17pm
Reviewers
Moderators
1 May 2011
Offline Life has moved on, expanded editions with bonus tracks are the norm. I would have no issue with single expanded discs being the standard with the related b-sides, oddities and outtakes, as long as they are clearly marketed as such. I wouldn’t be in favour of revising the original track listings.
Back in the 90’s I had the first four albums in stereo on bootleg digipacks which contained outtakes as extras and loved them. They were far more enjoyable than just the standard album as there was more songs.
The following people thank meanmistermustard for this post:
Richard, Rube"I told you everything I could about me, Told you everything I could" ('Before Believing' - Emmylou Harris)
3.37pm
21 September 2022
Offline http://www.beatlesebooks.com/s…..orever
This site states that it was considered that Strawberry Fields/When I’m 64 be a single.
When would people think that this iteration would have come out and what would its’s reputation have been
