- Page 2 of 3
- « Previous
- 1
- 2
- 3
- Next »
In the studio
The Beatles started recording Hey Jude on 29 July 1968. That first session was more of a rehearsal than a proper session: The Beatles knew it would be their next single, and dedicated the time to perfecting the arrangement.
Paul McCartney sang and played piano, John Lennon was on acoustic guitar, George Harrison played electric guitar and Ringo Starr was on drums. They recorded six takes, only three of which were complete, and each notably shorter than the final version. One of these was later released on Anthology 3.
On Hey Jude, when we first sat down and I sang 'Hey Jude...', George went 'nanu nanu' on his guitar. I continued, 'Don't make it bad...' and he replied 'nanu nanu'. He was answering every line - and I said, 'Whoa! Wait a minute, now. I don't think we want that. Maybe you'd come in with answering lines later. For now I think I should start it simply first.' He was going, 'Oh yeah, OK, fine, fine.' But it was getting a bit like that. He wasn't into what I was saying...I did want to insist that there shouldn't be an answering guitar phrase in Hey Jude - and that was important to me - but of course if you tell a guitarist that, and he's not as keen on the idea as you are, it looks as if you're knocking him out of the picture. I think George felt that: it was like, 'Since when are you going to tell me what to play? I'm in The Beatles too.' So I can see his point of view.
Anthology
The next evening The Beatles continued working on the track, recording takes 7-23. George Harrison didn't perform, so waited in the studio control room. The session was filmed for a documentary by the National Music Council of Great Britain, who captured the group playing and chatting for a short colour film called Music!
At the end of the session George Martin made a rough mix of the song, in order to score it for the orchestra that was booked for 1 August.
Hey Jude has become a classic. It felt good recording it. We put it down a couple of times - trying to get it right - and, like everything else, it just clicked. That's how it should be.
Anthology
On 31 July The Beatles decamped to Trident, a studio in London's Wardour Street, which had eight-track recording facilities. They began re-recording Hey Jude, laying down four takes of the song's rhythm track.
There is an amusing story about recording it. We were at Trident Studios in Soho, and Ringo walked out to go to the toilet and I hadn't noticed. The toilet was only a few yards from his drum booth, but he'd gone past my back and I still thought he was in his drum booth. I started what was the actual take, and Hey Jude goes on for hours before the drums come in and while I was doing it I suddenly felt Ringo tiptoeing past my back rather quickly, trying to get to his drums. And just as he got to his drums, boom boom boom, his timing was absolutely impeccable. So I think when those things happen, you have a little laugh and a light bulb goes off in your head and you think, This is the take! And you put a little more into it. You think, oh, fuck! This has got to be the take, what just happened was so magic! So we did that and we made a pretty good record.
Many Years From Now, Barry Miles
The song was completed the next day. McCartney added his bass and lead vocals, and the other Beatles contributed backing vocals. Then the 36-strong orchestra added backing for Hey Jude's lengthy four-chord coda The classical musicians were also offered a double fee for clapping and singing along to the 'nah nah nah' chant.
Most of the musicians were happy to oblige, especially as it meant a doubled fee, but there was one dissenter who reportedly walked out, saying "I'm not going to clap my hands and sing Paul McCartney's bloody song!"
Mark Lewisohn
Hey Jude contains an unedited expletive, which is often played by radio stations to this day. In the final verse, John Lennon sang "Let her into" instead of "Let her under your skin". His cry of "Oh!", followed by "Fucking hell", remains in the final mix.
I was told about it at the time but could never hear it. But once I had it pointed out I can't miss it now. I have a sneaking suspicion they knew all along, as it was a track that should have been pulled out in the mix. I would imagine it was one of those things that happened - it was a mistake, they listened to it and thought, 'doesn't matter, it's fine'.
The Complete Beatles Recording Sessions, Mark Lewisohn
- Page 2 of 3
- « Previous
- 1
- 2
- 3
- Next »
Related articles:
- Filming: Hey Jude, Revolution
- Mixing: Hey Jude
- US single release: Hey Jude
- Recording: Hey Jude
- Tape copying, recording: Hey Jude, Not Guilty
It might be their most commercially successful single but not their best seller. That is I Want To Hold Your Hand. See Wikipedia, Beatles.com or any list of world top selling singles.
My favourite McCartney song with the Beatles. Sounds brand new everytime I play it, which is a lot.
Right after the lyric "Remember, to let her under your skin.."
at 2:57 you can faintly hear a "OHHH!" followed by "Wrong chord! Fucking hell!"
'Scuse my language, but I think it's fun to listen for.
Hi Mark. On page two of this article I mentioned that:
"Hey Jude contains an unedited expletive, which is often played by radio stations to this day. In the final verse, John Lennon sang "Let her into" instead of "Let her under your skin". His cry of "Oh!", followed by "Fucking hell", remains in the final mix."
Was it a wrong chord or a wrong lyric? I can't make out the words "wrong chord", but listening to it again, I'm not convinced he gets the lyrics wrong either.
My understanding is that it is Paul McCartney who utters the expletive because he got the piano part wrong. Because John was regarded as the "rebel" he was rather amused by this and asked the engineers to leave it in. However, they mixed it very low and you can hear it only if you listen closely. Wikipedia says that Paul says "Hit the wrong chord!" before he utters the expletive. The cited source for its information is Geoff Emerick in 2006, one of the audio engineers present during the recording. I think this should be researched because this site is the first time I've read that it was John who said it.
George doesnt play anything on this song. Just backin vocals
Not true - he's there, playing his Telecaster, though it's only a minor part. You can hear him between 1'23 and 1'28, and playing subsequent fills, though his pride was hurt when McCartney told him not to play the answering lines in the verses. That's why he took a back seat during rehearsals on 30 July (he was in the control room with George Martin while the other three worked on the song), and only played a small role in the recording.
And I have seen a video of this session. Just John, Paul and Ringo - and it sounded great. Those boys could really nail it when they wanted to.
George really should've been given an extended solo so he could wail away with Paul for the last two minutes or so of the track. I'm thinking of something like the solo on the Velvet Underground's "Oh, Sweet Nothin'" - or, closer to home, Clapton's gently weeping solo. That would've fit nicely, and George really could've used the ego boost. As it is, it really does get a bit tedious, but I guess Paul didn't think so, since he had the full structurea all mapped out beforehand.
George did give himself the opportunity to "wail away" on the extended fade-out of the not completely dissimilar Isn't It a Pity (which, coincidentally, is just a couple of seconds longer than Hey Jude).
Yeah, that's a good comparison, but George was certainly entitled to indulge himself on his own album! My point is that it would've been a nice gesture if Paul had been less control-freaky and devised some way of allowing George to make some kind of notable contribution. Even if there was no room for a lead guitar at all in the arrangement, George was certainly capable of handling the bass guitar duty while Paul stuck to piano, if Paul had thought to ask.
I think George did play bass guitar. They talk about the right handed 6 six string fender bass in the studio on the Anthology. George also mentions in interviews that he played bass for some Paul songs. Also, on the Hey Jude Video It looks to me George is playing that big Bass. I haven't listen closely to hear bass on the record. Is there?
Yes. I think it's obvious. I also heard that George played that as well.
At 5:37 someone says in portuguese "Pega o Cavaquinho" wich in english means "take the cavaquinho".
OMFG. I speak portuguese, and I never noticed this, but now, I listened it again, and I noticed it too. It's SO weird. Maybe it's just a bunch of indecipherable words in english, we listen to it and it seems something that our mind assimilates to a word we know.
At 5:37 Paul says, "The pain won't come back Jude.” In English (which is far more likely to be uttered by an English singer) this means "the pain won't come back, Jude."
It makes sense, but I think that my mind is already used to "pega o cavaquinho", so I just can't hear what you said.
Paul does seem at times to have been too bossy in the studio but I think the writer of a song does have the right to final say as to how it should be done. Axing the answering back guitar idea was a good one.
Yeah, that answering wouldn't have worked well at all in the verses. I still think it would've worked really nicely during the final minutes, though, right to the fade-out. It's a free-for-all, Paul's testifying, George joins in - it'd be just like what George and Eric Clapton did during the "...Gently Weeps" fade, except the mood is celebratory rather than mournful. (Think of George's Leslie-speaker soloing in "Let It Be" - that's very close to the sound I'm thinking about.)
Well, someone had to fill the leadership void left by Lennon, and Paul was the better equipped to do it. A group without a leader or moderator gets nothing accomplished.
I also agree with you in that the writer of a song should get the final word. I mean, no one could have talked George out of all the sitars.
At 5:37 I hear John's voice. For years i have listened trying to figure out his words...it sounds like "Aint lookin back,Jude"
Still, I can't believe that the song was written for Julian, John Lennon's son. It's an amazing song, and a very great inspiration.
Paul Swore
John told the engineers to keep it but Paul swore
If you watch the video of the david frost show. I think it's pretty clear, George is playing 6 string Fender Bass. Now, thats probably not the released recorded version of the song, But we now know that Paul played alot of lead guitar, Drums, both George and John played Bass on some records.
Actually, John said after George misfires on his guitar, " you fucked it up ". This you can clearly hear if you listen closely.
Doubtful. George is barely on the song - he plays during the transitions back into the verses (at 1'23" and subsequent points) only.
I've never heard Paul comment on John's belief that the song was written about him, though I know Paul has always insisted its about Julian. But looking at the lyrics, the song makes a lot more sense being about John, talking about movements and "go out and get her" and "remember to let her into your heart." Doesn't make much sense as a message to a 6 year old boy.
I always think of John anyway when I hear this
I see it as Paul speaking to both Julian and John. The "sad song" being the parting of Julian's parents... "anytime you feel the pain" are more comforting words to him from Paul. Then it sounds like Paul turns to focus his attention toward his long-time friend John with the all too obvious "you were made to go out and get her" and other lines on Lennon's quickly blossoming relationship with Yoko.
Pauls inspiration and creativity is much different than Johns. Take "Martha My Dear" & "Jet" both songs about his dogs! But not really about his dogs. Maybe a line or two and then he just goes off the reservation. So, Hey Jude could start out about Julian, then about John, maybe even his girl friend Franny Schwartz. (Which she says in her book)
Haven't seen it mentioned - "Hey Jude" was loosely based on "Save The Last Dance For Me".
As I understand it, Ringo had essentially just returned from his self-imposed exile from the Beatles in time to film the David Frost show. Ringo has made what I think is a peculiar comment about "Hey Jude" that always made me wonder what his thinking is. I can't be verbatim right now, but he has stated that he has no interest in playing 'Hey Jude" again because he has already played it once. I find this odd because in concert Ringo is found playing a number of songs that he has already played dozens of times. Why is he hostile toward "Hey Jude"? My belief is that it stems from some grudge he'd had with Paul, a frequent afterhours studioholic, coming in and redubbing some of Ringo's drumming. Of course, this song being manifested during the legnedary "White Album" period where Paul was overbearing in the studio and would frequently forsake the group concept to cover all instruments on his own if he could get away with it. Any other ideas?
You know, I read the same thing (though not specifying which song) that claimed Paul had overdubbed drum on a song in '68 and Ringo had to pretend that he did not notice during the playback the following day. I think it was a Peter Brown book. Not sure. I commented about it somewhere, and was responded to by someone with an emphatic "never happened." No details, so who knows. Obviously, it is a rumour at least, perhaps the reason Starr walked out. If true, I don't blame him at all.
Pretty sure Paul played drums on Back In The USSR during Ringo's absence from the band.
Paul was already "overbearing". The White Album became every man for himself. 3 separate camps. My guess is Ringo was the odd man out. He was probably treated like one of the EMI staff. Think about this, only 2 months later, Paul pulled them altogher to do the Let it Be project...Being filmed in the studio. It turned out badly, but the music was great! John & Paul worked together/sang together on the music and it was George who walked out. John's advice was to get Eric Clapton to take his place.
That incident in question was indeed reported in Brown's "The Love You Make".
I used to think the long fade out was cool
(as a rebellious idea) but now it's kinda tiring having to listen all the way through. This song should have been 4:30.
In hindsight, george should have got the guitar solo on Hey Jude instead of the long fade out. But, Paul gave George the solo on Let It Be and it wasn't very good. George knew enough to re-do the solo for the album version. The Lads wanted to stop touring. Paul didn't. Paul took advantage of all the studio time to create great music. Paul was the Beatles from Revolver to Abbey Road. Maybe even from mid - 1965.
I always thought not just because of the video but George played the Bass