What Beatles song might have sounded better (or worse) with a different singer? | Page 2 | Yesterday... and today | Fab forum

Please consider registering
Guest

Log In Register

Register | Lost password?
Advanced Search

— Forum Scope —

  

— Match —

   

— Forum Options —

   

Wildcard usage:
*  matches any number of characters    %  matches exactly one character

Minimum search word length is 4 characters - maximum search word length is 84 characters

What Beatles song might have sounded better (or worse) with a different singer?
3 November 2013
4.45pm
Linde
The Netherlands
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2039
Member Since:
21 November 2012
Offline
21

Woah. Had never heard that In My Life cover before. That really sucks some hairy monkeyballs.

It's slow, his voice is even worse than I expected. What the hell George, it doesn't even sound like you! I also couldn't understand half of what he was mumbling, and surely not the bit about missing the others. You could tell me anything about what he's singing in this one and I'll believe it, really.

3 November 2013
9.45pm
Funny Paper
America
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 1981
Member Since:
1 November 2012
Offline
22

Linde said
Woah. Had never heard that In My Life cover before. That really sucks some hairy monkeyballs.

Thanks for the hearty laugh that gave me…blue-meanie

Faded flowers, wait in a jar, till the evening is complete... complete... complete... complete...
3 November 2013
9.50pm
Funny Paper
America
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 1981
Member Since:
1 November 2012
Offline
23

Interesting, I've given some thought to my original post, but I can't seem to come up with any more Beatles songs that would sound good (or even interesting) if the singers were switched around. Perhaps Ringo doing "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" and "Long and Winding Road" -- basically any of Paul's "granny" music might sound interesting with Ringo singing it (also "Your Mother Should Know")…

Faded flowers, wait in a jar, till the evening is complete... complete... complete... complete...
3 November 2013
9.55pm
meanmistermustard
Moderator



Forum Posts: 9765
Member Since:
1 May 2011
Offline

Would have liked to have heard just one take of John singing Why Don't We Do It In The Road?? His voice would surely be great for that.

There is supposedly an outtake of Paul singing I Want You (She's So Heavy) but it's almost certainly not (not the Get Back sessions version). What do you think?

 

The following people thank meanmistermustard for this post:

Oudis
"Well, probably we'll sell less records, less people'll go to see the film, we'll write less songs, and we'll all die of failure" (John Lennon 8/64)
3 November 2013
9.58pm
Ron Nasty
"Where have you been?" "I'm not telling you..."
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 3032
Member Since:
17 December 2012
Offline
25

Sorry, FP, I did derail it a bit by posting George's In My Life!

"I only said we were bigger than Rod... and now there's all this!" Ron Nasty
7 December 2013
1.03am
IveJustSeenAFaceo
Somewhere other than where you are.
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2616
Member Since:
1 November 2013
Offline
26

Hadn't really thought about this, but Paul's Concert for George rendition of For You Blue is absolutely beautiful. I think that could have sounded pretty good. It's still good with George, though.

(This signature brought to you by Winter. Coming for an abnormally long amount of time.)
7 December 2013
2.27am
trcanberra
Canberra, ACT
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 1682
Member Since:
29 August 2013
Offline
27

Someone else doing Good Night off the White Album – not sure who, but doesn't seem to suit Ringo.

The following people thank trcanberra for this post:

Oudis
7 December 2013
2.32am
IveJustSeenAFaceo
Somewhere other than where you are.
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2616
Member Since:
1 November 2013
Offline
28

trcanberra said
Someone else doing Good Night off the White Album – not sure who, but doesn't seem to suit Ringo.

Actually, John sang on the demo, and in Geoff Emerick's book, he calls it beautiful, and says Ringo did a respectable job, but when John did it, it was incredible. Sorry, don't remember the exact quote but that little bit stuck out to me.

The following people thank IveJustSeenAFaceo for this post:

Oudis
(This signature brought to you by Winter. Coming for an abnormally long amount of time.)
7 December 2013
4.41am
trcanberra
Canberra, ACT
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 1682
Member Since:
29 August 2013
Offline
29

IveJustSeenAFaceo said

trcanberra said
Someone else doing Good Night off the White Album – not sure who, but doesn't seem to suit Ringo.

Actually, John sang on the demo, and in Geoff Emerick's book, he calls it beautiful, and says Ringo did a respectable job, but when John did it, it was incredible. Sorry, don't remember the exact quote but that little bit stuck out to me.

Nice – I half had John in mind.

 

7 December 2013
6.00pm
Linde
The Netherlands
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2039
Member Since:
21 November 2012
Offline
30

trcanberra said
Someone else doing Good Night off the White Album – not sure who, but doesn't seem to suit Ringo.

I think it does suit Ringo, but I think John would be a better fit. He wrote it with Julian in mind so he could probably sing it with a different kind of emotion than Ringo. 

 

Which doesn't really make sense because Ringo also had 2 sons by then, but I hope people will get what I mean. John wrote it so it's more personal for him

The following people thank Linde for this post:

Oudis
7 December 2013
8.02pm
parlance
Slaggers
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 5109
Member Since:
8 November 2012
Offline

meanmistermustard said
There is supposedly an outtake of Paul singing I Want You (She's So Heavy) but it's almost certainly not (not the Get Back sessions version). What do you think?

 

It sounds too generic for Paul. Or if it is him, he didn't warm up to the song, making John the better choice for it.

parlance

Beware of sadness. It can hit you. It can hurt you. Make you sore and what is more, that is not what you are here for. - George

Check out my fan video for Paul's song "Appreciate" at YouTube and Vimeo.

8 December 2013
4.21pm
FizzleJayWay
London, UK
The Jacaranda
Forum Posts: 27
Member Since:
29 November 2013
Offline
32

meanmistermustard said
Would have liked to have heard just one take of John singing Why Don't We Do It In The Road?? His voice would surely be great for that.

There is supposedly an outtake of Paul singing I Want You (She's So Heavy) but it's almost certainly not (not the Get Back sessions version). What do you think?

 

I don't know about this… The roughness in John's voice really makes this song it sounds quite clean and I agree with Parlance it does sound generic with Paul's voice if that makes any sense

But if you want money for people with minds that hate... All I can tell you is brother you have to wait. Alright.

8 December 2013
7.02pm
IveJustSeenAFaceo
Somewhere other than where you are.
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2616
Member Since:
1 November 2013
Offline
33

I believe parlance's point was that it wasn't Paul. It sounds to generic to be Paul, not that it sounds generic because of Paul. Correct me if I misunderstood. 

(This signature brought to you by Winter. Coming for an abnormally long amount of time.)
8 December 2013
7.04pm
parlance
Slaggers
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 5109
Member Since:
8 November 2012
Offline
34

IveJustSeenAFaceo said
I believe parlance's point was that it wasn't Paul. It sounds to generic to be Paul, not that it sounds generic because of Paul. Correct me if I misunderstood. 

Oh, yes. Sorry, I didn't see the previous post. That's what I meant exactly.

parlance

Beware of sadness. It can hit you. It can hurt you. Make you sore and what is more, that is not what you are here for. - George

Check out my fan video for Paul's song "Appreciate" at YouTube and Vimeo.

8 December 2013
7.28pm
IveJustSeenAFaceo
Somewhere other than where you are.
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2616
Member Since:
1 November 2013
Offline
35

It sounds like Paul to me, though.

(This signature brought to you by Winter. Coming for an abnormally long amount of time.)
18 December 2013
5.13pm
ScrambledEggs
Behind the moon
Hollywood Bowl
Forum Posts: 306
Member Since:
16 December 2013
Offline
36

"Why Don't We Do It In The Road??" always sounded like a John song to me. I'm quite certain he would have done a good job singing it.

19 December 2013
6.43pm
Into the Sky with Diamonds
New York
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 1285
Member Since:
10 August 2011
Offline
37

The only vocal change I would have made to any Beatle recording is ironically enough on "In My Life." No, I wouldn't have had George sing it…

I would have subtracted Paul. This is the only song of theirs where I find the harmony less than helpful. Granted, I understand that according to Paul he wrote the melody, so it's natural that he would have wanted to be in on it. But I think it would have been better with John alone. It would have sounded more like this great rendition:

"Into the Sky with Diamonds" (the Beatles and the Race to the Moon – a history)
8 June 2014
2.43pm
MrMoonlight
Alone in the clouds all blue...
Rishikesh
Forum Posts: 789
Member Since:
2 April 2014
Offline

So for a few years now there's been controversy over whether this is real or not. From the viewpoints I've seen, it's more or less an equal verdict. I've seen plenty of conflicting stories on the comments section, but thankfully, this isn't YouTube.

As for me, the instruments and the tuning sound exactly like they do on the original, and it really sounds like Paul in the lead. It's even got the slight vibrato in his voice you can hear at times during the later years – so I really want to believe.

Note by Ahhh Girl 10 June 2014: Posts 38-41 originally were a thread titled " I Want You (She's So Heavy) Alternate Take – Real or Fake?"

Mal's got a mop and another glass of orange juice!
~He took the mirrors off his Cadillac
'Cause he doesn't like looking like he looks back~
8 June 2014
3.12pm
meanmistermustard
Moderator



Forum Posts: 9765
Member Since:
1 May 2011
Offline

Its certainly not Ringo's normal drumming style and with it supposedly being Paul on vocals who is drumming?

I've wanted it to be them but wanting to and it actually being are two different things. Its not the Beatles for me.

 

Note: This topic has been addressed in this thread (posts 24, 31 – 35).

"Well, probably we'll sell less records, less people'll go to see the film, we'll write less songs, and we'll all die of failure" (John Lennon 8/64)
8 June 2014
8.45pm
Necko
Rishikesh
Forum Posts: 824
Member Since:
11 November 2010
Offline
40

I have no idea.  I've heard plenty of arguments from both sides.  Whoever is singing certainly does sound a lot like Paul McCartney.  I'm constantly on the fence about this one.

I'm Necko.  I'm like Ringo except I wear necklaces.
Forum Timezone: Europe/London

Most Users Ever Online: 597

Currently Online: Oudis, Sugarplum fairy
46 Guest(s)

Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)

Top Posters:

meanmistermustard: 9765

mr. Sun king coming together: 6916

parlance: 5109

Ahhh Girl: 4956

mithveaen: 4651

Annadog40: 4147

Zig: 4100

Mr. Kite: 3679

Ron Nasty: 3032

fabfouremily: 2934

Member Stats:

Guest Posters: 88

Members: 2594

Moderators: 4

Admins: 2

Forum Stats:

Groups: 3

Forums: 34

Topics: 3159

Posts: 134034

Newest Members: Mazza, AllMyLoving, KenO, mrneil2, macdog

Moderators: Ahhh Girl (4956), meanmistermustard (9765), Zig (4100), Joe (3451)

Administrators: Joe (3451), Ellie (1)

Members Birthdays
Today: None
Upcoming: None