Which Beatle Do You Prefer Singing The "Screaming" Songs? John Or Paul? | Page 2 | Fab Forum

Introducing the inaugural Fab Forum February Fundraiser! Click here for more details.

Please consider registering
Guest

sp_LogInOut Log In sp_Registration Register

Register | Lost password?
Advanced Search

— Forum Scope —






— Match —





— Forum Options —





Minimum search word length is 4 characters - maximum search word length is 84 characters

sp_Feed sp_TopicIcon
Which Beatle Do You Prefer Singing The "Screaming" Songs? John Or Paul?
No permission to create posts
24 June 2012
11.57pm
Avatar
kelicopter
Sitting in an English Garden
Shea Stadium
Forum Posts: 421
Member Since:
6 November 2010
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Ooh I love them both, but the first five seconds of Mr Moonlight means I have to lean towards John.

"Life is what happens to you while you're busy making other plans."
"When I cannot sing my heart, I can only speak my mind."
17 July 2012
7.32pm
Avatar
Old Siam Sir
The Jacaranda
Forum Posts: 28
Member Since:
21 May 2012
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

a-hard-days-night-paul-11Paul wins in my opinion. He nailed the cat scream every time he tried it. John's voice might have been more distinctive but Paul's was, by far, more versatile! Examples: Oh! Darling, Can't Buy Me Love, I'm Down, The Night Before, Hey Jude (last section), Helter Skelter, etc. Solo Examples: Monkberry Moon Delight, Maybe I'm Amazed, Old Siam Sir, Rode All Night, Soily, etc. And the best example of Paul's vocal power: Oh Woman, Oh Why - probably his best vocal performance and a great showcase of his screaming! John's screams sounded like screaming, Paul's were more like soulful grit. He had that same quality that Rod Stewart had or Steven Tyler or Janis Joplin. And he could sing smooth and beautiful as well!

1-2-3-4-5-6-7-All Good Children go to Heaven
17 July 2012
11.09pm
Avatar
Buzzy
UK
A Beginning
Forum Posts: 7
Member Since:
25 June 2012
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

I honestly do prefer Paul's overall but I don't think many of his songs match the power in Twist And Shout.

Oh! Darling, I'm Down & Helter Skelter and like 3 of my Favourite Paul songs so I think I just prefer Paul's shouting out of Paul's songs. 

Maybe I'm Amazed is an epic song with such range, and on Live And Let Die is awesome (especially the you gotta give the fellow hell bit)

18 July 2012
3.40pm
Avatar
IMDeWalrus
Terrace BC Canada
Abbey Road
Forum Posts: 97
Member Since:
26 July 2011
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

For me, this is just another example of how John Lennon and Paul McCartney came out pretty much equal in their abilities.   Both were excellent singers, songwriters and musicians.  (Paul is always considered a much better guitarist -- and I suppose he was -- but John played great guitar on "I Feel Fine", "You Can't Do That", "Get Back" and "All My Loving" -- among many other songs.)

 

In terms of the best "screaming" vocals, I'd probably give the edge (as I usually do) to John -- especially on songs like "Twist & Shout", "You Can't Do That" (his shout as the band goes into his guitar solo), "I Want You (She's So Heavy)", "Yer Blues" and on his solo song "Meat City" (on the MIND GAMES album).

 

But Paul does a terrific job on "Long Tall Sally", "Hey Jude", "I'm Down", "Maybe I'm Amazed" to name a few.  

I've got nothing to say, but it's okay.. GOOD MORNING! GOOD MORNING!! GOOD MORNING!!!
21 July 2012
2.15am
Avatar
Long John Silver
Hollywood Bowl
Forum Posts: 366
Member Since:
9 May 2012
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

IMDeWalrus said
For me, this is just another example of how
John Lennon and Paul McCartney came out pretty much equal in their abilities.   Both were excellent singers, songwriters and musicians.  (Paul is always considered a much better guitarist -- and I suppose he was -- but John played great guitar on "I Feel Fine", "You Can't Do That", "Get Back" and "All My Loving" -- among many other songs.)

 

In terms of the best "screaming" vocals, I'd probably give the edge (as I usually do) to John -- especially on songs like "Twist & Shout", "You Can't Do That" (his shout as the band goes into his guitar solo), "I Want You (She's So Heavy)", "Yer Blues" and on his solo song "Meat City" (on the MIND GAMES album).

 

But Paul does a terrific job on "Long Tall Sally", "Hey Jude", "I'm Down", "Maybe I'm Amazed" to name a few.  

I've never heard about Paul being a better guitarist? I don't say he isn't, just that I've never heard about that. He was a better bass player that's for sure, not sure about guitar.

Living is easy with eyes closed, misunderstanding all you see.
21 July 2012
11.03am
Ben Ramon
Candlestick Park
Forum Posts: 619
Member Since:
26 March 2012
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Long John Silver said

IMDeWalrus said
For me, this is just another example of how
John Lennon and Paul McCartney came out pretty much equal in their abilities.   Both were excellent singers, songwriters and musicians.  (Paul is always considered a much better guitarist -- and I suppose he was -- but John played great guitar on "I Feel Fine", "You Can't Do That", "Get Back" and "All My Loving" -- among many other songs.)

 

In terms of the best "screaming" vocals, I'd probably give the edge (as I usually do) to John -- especially on songs like "Twist & Shout", "You Can't Do That" (his shout as the band goes into his guitar solo), "I Want You (She's So Heavy)", "Yer Blues" and on his solo song "Meat City" (on the MIND GAMES album).

 

But Paul does a terrific job on "Long Tall Sally", "Hey Jude", "I'm Down", "Maybe I'm Amazed" to name a few.  

I've never heard about Paul being a better guitarist? I don't say he isn't, just that I've never heard about that. He was a better bass player that's for sure, not sure about guitar.

The absolute majority of people I've spoken to on the subject rate both George and Paul above John on guitar. I think all three were good in their own way but technically Paul was more skilled than John. I don't see John ever whacking out anything in the calibre of the Too Many People or Taxman solos.

SHUT UP - Paulie's talkin'
21 July 2012
12.10pm
Avatar
meanmistermustard
Moderator



Forum Posts: 17138
Member Since:
1 May 2011
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

John felt slighted in his guitar playing to the point of highlighting in an interview what he felt was some great rhythm guitar, the one i remember being All My Loving. Paul was praised and respected in the press for his bass playing, Ringo for his drumming and George for his solos but John was normally overlooked in that department.

Don’t make your love suffer insecurities, trade the baggage of self to set another one free. ('Paper Skin' - Kendall Payne)
21 July 2012
12.22pm
Avatar
Long John Silver
Hollywood Bowl
Forum Posts: 366
Member Since:
9 May 2012
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Ben Ramon said

Long John Silver said

IMDeWalrus said
For me, this is just another example of how
John Lennon and Paul McCartney came out pretty much equal in their abilities.   Both were excellent singers, songwriters and musicians.  (Paul is always considered a much better guitarist -- and I suppose he was -- but John played great guitar on "I Feel Fine", "You Can't Do That", "Get Back" and "All My Loving" -- among many other songs.)

 

In terms of the best "screaming" vocals, I'd probably give the edge (as I usually do) to John -- especially on songs like "Twist & Shout", "You Can't Do That" (his shout as the band goes into his guitar solo), "I Want You (She's So Heavy)", "Yer Blues" and on his solo song "Meat City" (on the MIND GAMES album).

 

But Paul does a terrific job on "Long Tall Sally", "Hey Jude", "I'm Down", "Maybe I'm Amazed" to name a few.  

I've never heard about Paul being a better guitarist? I don't say he isn't, just that I've never heard about that. He was a better bass player that's for sure, not sure about guitar.

The absolute majority of people I've spoken to on the subject rate both George and Paul above John on guitar. I think all three were good in their own way but technically Paul was more skilled than John. I don't see John ever whacking out anything in the calibre of the Too Many People or Taxman solos.

Maybe, but when someone plays instrument for over 10 years, probably could play Taxman, Too Many People etc... they are not that much complicated songs.

Living is easy with eyes closed, misunderstanding all you see.
21 July 2012
1.35pm
Ben Ramon
Candlestick Park
Forum Posts: 619
Member Since:
26 March 2012
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Long John Silver said

Ben Ramon said

Long John Silver said

IMDeWalrus said
For me, this is just another example of how
John Lennon and Paul McCartney came out pretty much equal in their abilities.   Both were excellent singers, songwriters and musicians.  (Paul is always considered a much better guitarist -- and I suppose he was -- but John played great guitar on "I Feel Fine", "You Can't Do That", "Get Back" and "All My Loving" -- among many other songs.)

 

In terms of the best "screaming" vocals, I'd probably give the edge (as I usually do) to John -- especially on songs like "Twist & Shout", "You Can't Do That" (his shout as the band goes into his guitar solo), "I Want You (She's So Heavy)", "Yer Blues" and on his solo song "Meat City" (on the MIND GAMES album).

 

But Paul does a terrific job on "Long Tall Sally", "Hey Jude", "I'm Down", "Maybe I'm Amazed" to name a few.  

I've never heard about Paul being a better guitarist? I don't say he isn't, just that I've never heard about that. He was a better bass player that's for sure, not sure about guitar.

The absolute majority of people I've spoken to on the subject rate both George and Paul above John on guitar. I think all three were good in their own way but technically Paul was more skilled than John. I don't see John ever whacking out anything in the calibre of the Too Many People or Taxman solos.

Maybe, but when someone plays instrument for over 10 years, probably could play Taxman, Too Many People etc... they are not that much complicated songs.

Not from a rhythm guitarist's perspective, but the guitar solos in them are difficult.

SHUT UP - Paulie's talkin'
12 February 2014
11.32pm
Avatar
Be Sharps
The Kaiserkeller
Forum Posts: 55
Member Since:
5 February 2014
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Zig said


. I don't think Paul sounds awkward on any songs but will say that on songs like "
Oh! Darling", he does come off as sounding a bit forced. That is not a knock on him, just an observation.

P:I agree with John on "Oh! Darling".Paul should have let John si

Zig said

kedame said
I guess it really depends on the song. I don't think Paul sounds awkward at all on songs like Long Tall Sally or She's A Woman, and he really kills Helter Skelter. I'm not sure where you get that he sounds awkward at all...

Go take a listen to Monkberry Moon Delight or Rode All Night.

However, I do love John's screaming in Twist And Shout and Yer Blues. It's raw and emotional.

I get more of a kick out of Paul screaming simply because he can do the softer ballads so well, too.

I agree with the portions of your post that I have bolded. I don't think Paul sounds awkward on any songs but will say that on songs like "Oh! Darling", he does come off as sounding a bit forced. That is not a knock on him, just an observation.

In any event, I would kill (OK - give someone a paper cut) to have his range!paul-mccartney

I agree with John on "Oh! Darling".Paul should have let John have a go at it.Paul just sounds forced on it.

You've got a lucky face.

13 February 2014
12.57am
Avatar
PeterWeatherby
A Park in the Dark
Hollywood Bowl
Forum Posts: 370
Member Since:
5 February 2010
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Paul had the naturally higher vocal range, so he's able to do more with the full-voice screaming than John. The top note in the "Mr. Moonlight" intro is a B-flat, I believe, but the Anthology outtakes reveal that John had a hard time getting there. Heck, he had a hard time getting to the high A in the chorus of "No Reply" ("I saw the liiight"), so he eventually relegated that part to Paul, just as he handed over the bridge of "A Hard Day's Night" to Paul because he couldn't hit the repeated high G's, F#'s, and screamin' high A at the end. "Anytime at All" is another example - Paul gets the second "anytime at all" in the chorus because it went too high for John, and again, it was only an A.

All of that to say, John could hit the occasional high screamer note if it was a somewhat isolated instance in the song, but even then he seems to have topped out around an A or maybe a B-flat on a good day. With that in mind, "Oh Darling" has that bridge that just freakin' camps out on high B's and A's, and I have absolutely no doubt that this would have been way out of John's range and ability. Not only does that bridge go higher than I've ever heard John sing, but it stays up there for longer than John could have done. (Listen to the end of "Instant Karma" and how the repeated high G's in the chorus eventually force John to start speak-singing because his voice can't sustain the punishment - and those are lower notes than the ones found in "Oh Darling".)

They could both scream, but John had a limit as to how high he could go and how often he could go there. Paul's screaming stuff is more razor-sharp and closer to the actual notes as well, whereas John's screams tended to splatter a bit (as in "Mother").

Not a bit like Cagney.
13 February 2014
1.06am
Avatar
PeterWeatherby
A Park in the Dark
Hollywood Bowl
Forum Posts: 370
Member Since:
5 February 2010
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

One quick exception to the rule that I just thought of: John's recording of "What You Got." It's an absolute anomaly given everything he'd said in the past about not being able to reach certain notes, and so rearranging "Hard Day's Night," "Anytime at All," "No Reply," and so on. Because in the chorus of "What You Got," he hits that high B repeatedly ("You don't know what you got ..."), and then tops out with a high C# at the end of the chorus ("give me one more chance").

I have no idea how he hit those notes, or how many re-takes it took to get there, but it flies in the face of everything he ever said about his range.

Not a bit like Cagney.
13 February 2014
3.10am
Avatar
Mr. Kite
910 Penny Lane, Strawberry Fields, Pepperland
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 6092
Member Since:
4 February 2014
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

I believe I'm going to have to go with Paul as he has such range, for example when he hits those high notes in Why Don't We Do It In The Road?? He also has a trademark, for lack of better word, Paul voice for these songs (like in WDWIITR, I've Got A Feeling, Maybe I'm Amazed). Even if it is forced as some have pointed out. Johns voice is more raw and emotional but I think Paul wins BARELY!

If I spoke prose you'd all find out, I don't know what I talk about.

Can buy Joe love!
If you're shopping at one of these two websites use the links below to support the Beatles Bible:

Amazon | iTunes

No permission to create posts
Forum Timezone: America/Chicago

Most Users Ever Online: 597

Currently Online: Necko, Merch
33 Guest(s)

Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)

Top Posters:

meanmistermustard: 17138

Ahhh Girl: 10751

Annadog40: 9751

Zig: 7555

parlance: 7092

mr. Sun king coming together: 6980

Mr. Kite: 6092

Silly Girl: 5814

trcanberra: 5545

Ron Nasty: 4945

Member Stats:

Guest Posters: 87

Members: 3334

Moderators: 4

Admins: 2

Forum Stats:

Groups: 3

Forums: 42

Topics: 3815

Posts: 202250

Newest Members:

nicklav99, pbwriter, leenawilliams, ravenswolf, Gamer1234

Moderators: Ahhh Girl: 10751, meanmistermustard: 17138, Zig: 7555, Joe: 4390

Administrators: Joe: 4390, Ellie: 3

Members Birthdays
sp_BirthdayIcon
Today: None
Upcoming: DrBeatle