12 April 2012
I decided to make a thread about this song (which is one of my favourites) because I have a question: Which version of She Came In Through The Bathroom Window do you prefer the Anthology (Get Back Sessions) ballad version or the Abbey Road pop/rock version. I think the anthology version is very nice, but the Abbey Road is so awesome and would have been a ideal contender for the rooftop concert. It's hard for me to decide but I think I take the Abbey Road version. Which version do you prefer?
Edit: The Beatlesbible page of this song says that there are pianos on this song, but I don't hear them, can anyone tell me when they are audible i this song (and also in Polythene Pam)
10 August 2011
It's great fun to listen to the embryonic version of a song.
Most of the time the final version is best - IMO that's the case here. (I'd say the same for "While My Guitar ..." and "Strawberry Fields").
Collectively, the Beatles and George Martin had great judgment when it came to selecting takes.
1 May 2011
I do really like the slower rendition on A3, it really works well and its such a groove that they get into too. If it had appeared in this arrangement on Abbey Road then i think it would still have been loved but for different reasons. The upbeat style is better tho, it really rocks along and adds so much to the medley, bringing part 1 to a fabulous close, plus the transition from Polythene Pam with the guitar work and John and Paul's adlibs are wonderful. It leaves you gasping for breathe after building from Mr Mustard and thats why Golden Slumbers works so well, you can take a rest before Carry That Weight bursts onto the scene and you're off again.
The sequencing of the medley is something that could not be bettered. How they managed to take such unrelated songs and make them all not only work together but seem as if they are 1 i'll never know.
Im more likely to listen to A3 tho as the official take is so heavily associated with all the other tracks, you cant just play Bathroom Window you have to go back to at least You Never Give Me Your Money - possibly Come Together.
Not sure whereabouts the piano can be heard as i havent listened out for it but the basic track was Guitars, Drums and Piano. Maybe it got buried under the overdubs (additional piano parts were tried out but were left off the final mix).
Most Users Ever Online: 597
Currently Online: trcanberra, ewe2, JPM-Fangirl
Currently Browsing this Page:
Ahhh Girl: 7705
mr. Sun king coming together: 6931
Mr. Kite: 5896
Ron Nasty: 3838
Guest Posters: 88
Newest Members: willianayers9, SoaringSeagle, JohnnyAlpha, andrewjohn1317, JPM-Fangirl
Moderators: Ahhh Girl: 7705, meanmistermustard: 12815, Zig: 5691, Joe: 3902
Administrators: Joe: 3902, Ellie: 1