Log In
Register
3.22pm
4 April 2010
Offline
http://www.youtube.com/user/be…..boxset2009/
He’s uploaded every song (in stereo and mono) and included the mini-docs. Badass.
"The best band? The Beatles. The most overrated band? The Beatles."
4.50am
13 November 2009
Offline
Slightly illegal but still great. I’ve been to his channel a few times to compare my stereo songs to the mono ones. I really want that mono box set!
4.55am
4 April 2010
Offline I was going to post LennMcCaHarrStarr’s channel, but he got nailed for copyright. He made every part come out of a different speaker (I have 5.1). It sounded amazing, don’t know how he did it.
"The best band? The Beatles. The most overrated band? The Beatles."
9.01am
“Slightly illegal but still great. I’ve been to his channel a few times to compare my stereo songs to the mono ones. I really want that mono box set!”
12.36pm
4 April 2010
Offline Get the Rubber Soul and White Album ‘s in Stereo. They sound freaking amazing.
"The best band? The Beatles. The most overrated band? The Beatles."
1.23pm
13 November 2009
Offline thomas said:
Worth the money. I love the Mono and don’t plan to buy the stereo set. So far it knocks my socks off. I have yet to compare every stereo vs. mono, but the White Album differences will likely be the most interesting as I never heard it in mono (bought the original ’68 stereo vinyl and later tape.) One has to wonder though why they didn’t include these short documentaries in the Mono Box Set. Especially given what you pay for either set. Nothing new really, just short intro info most old fans already know, but nice little perks to have nevertheless. Hey Apple, get with the program: these are just as appropriate for the Mono buyers. Even more so since most albums were mixed by the Beatles themselves in mono. Including a seperate DVD of these documentary shorts in the Mono set would hardly have hurt their profit margins.
I guess they didn’t include the mini docos in the mono box sets because they were in the stereo box sets. Abbey Road and Let It Be aren’t in the mono set so they didn’t want to put only some of the docos in. They probably assumed most people would buy the stereo CDs and only fans would buy the mono CDs, and fans don’t need to know the info in docos – they’re just small bits of Anthology, stuff to introduce new listeners to the music. They wanted the mono CDs to be more like the LPs I think, so having the doco would kind of defeat that.
1.18am
“They probably assumed most people would buy the stereo CDs and only fans would buy the mono CDs, and fans don’t need to know the info in docos..”
I’m sure you’re right stereo outsells the mono. My intention though (perhaps others also) was to buy the Mono then add the remaining stereo remasters for a complete collection. Re-thinking that now. Two weeks ago I paid $239 at Amazon for the Mono, then the price dropped to $209.00 (#*&?!!) I complained and Amazon refunded the difference, so I _may_ get the Stereo Box (currently $180.00), but not for the docs. Fourteen albums/sixteen discs for an additional $150.00 is about $9 per disc. I’d spend close to half that for the 4 individual stereo discs not in the Mono box.
Plus as I mentioned while I’m impressed with the mono remasters, occasionally I find I prefer a song’s stereo version (an example is Help , where I prefer the stereo version of that individual song to the mono, though prefer the mono album overall.) Most other songs so far I’ve found superior in mono. But it would be nice to have both and compare, docs or no.
1.23am
“Get the Rubber Soul and White Album ‘s in Stereo. They sound freaking amazing.”
The Mono Box includes mono and stereo versions of Rubber Soul (also Help !) I have the 1987 CD of the White Album , but definitely want the 2009 remaster.
10.17am
1 April 2010
Offline I must be the only one who doesn’t understand the mono vs stereo thing. There is an obvious difference between these remasters and the versions I have on my iPod; I’m guessing they were the ones to come out in the 80s. But when the time comes to buy the box set, I don’t know which to get and/or feel like it’s sacrilege to drool over the stereo one.
Do what you want to do, and go where you're going to…
12.16pm
13 November 2009
Offline thomas said:
“Get the Rubber Soul and White Album ‘s in Stereo. They sound freaking amazing.”
The Mono Box includes mono and stereo versions of Rubber Soul (also Help !) I have the 1987 CD of the White Album , but definitely want the 2009 remaster.
The stereo versions of Help ! and Rubber Soul in the mono set are the original 60s mixes, which did not have much effort put into them. George Martin remixed them in the 80s when they were released on CD and those are versions in the stereo set. I haven’t heard the old stereo mixes, but I’m sure they’re not as good – they can’t possibly be really.
2.56pm
31 March 2008
Offline
MrBig said:
http://www.youtube.com/user/be…..boxset2009/
He’s uploaded every song (in stereo and mono) and included the mini-docs. Badass.
Can’t see this staying up too long. EMI are getting ever more vigilant with YouTube – a user I was following had his account closed because he was posting outtakes, though he reopened under a different name.
Also, I never understand why anyone bothers making videos out of music and posting them on YouTube. The amount of time it takes, for absolutely no reward, seems pretty pointless. Plus there’s no comparison in terms of sound quality between hearing a CD and a streamed Flash movie on the web.
McLerristarr – the 1965 stereo mixes of Help ! and Rubber Soul are worth hearing (both are in the mono box). The 1980s ones that are in the stereo box are probably more balanced, but not necessarily better IMO. I still don’t understand why they put the 65 stereo mixes in the mono box – they should have included both versions in the stereo box.
Jenn – if you have the what I call the premasters (pre-09/09/09) on your iPod, those are George Martin’s mixes made in the 1980s when The Beatles’ back catalogue was first issued on CD. The recent remasters were polished versions from the 1960s masters, and so included the mono and stereo mixes that were issued while The Beatles were together – making them the authentic 60s versions, only with a bit of EQ and noise reduction to make them sound better (caveat: some prefer vinyl – I won’t get drawn into that one here). Digital mastering technology has got better since the first CDs came out in the 80s, so it’s a big step forward in terms of sound quality.
As for which boxes to buy, well there are those that say the mono discs are the ones to get because The Beatles spent more time on them. Personally I think some of the albums, such as AHDN , sound better in stereo. There are many minor differences in the different versions, such as sound effects in Back In The USSR , Tomorrow Never Knows and Yellow Submarine ; Helter Skelter is longer in stereo, and I’m So Tired has extra harmonies in mono; Good Morning Good Morning sounds far bassier and better in mono; etc etc. The full details are too numerous to list here, and it doesn’t really matter too much if you’re more of a casual fan – just get the stereo as it has all the songs from 62-70, whereas the mono box stops with the White Album (68).
Can buy me love! Please consider supporting the Beatles Bible on Amazon
Or buy my paperback/ebook! Riding So High – The Beatles and Drugs
Don't miss The Bowie Bible – now live!
4.00pm
1 April 2010
Offline Ta for the explanation, Joe. They were probably the 80s mixes as I seem to remember the CDs in my Easter basket ca. 2002/3. I’m by no means a casual fan; just a broke student/live off a teacher’s wage fan, so it’s more a matter of which to get first, considering the slight overlap…but I reckon I’ll get the stereo first and then the mono. These boxes aren’t limited edition, are they?
Do what you want to do, and go where you're going to…
4.41pm
31 March 2008
Offline The mono one is supposed to be limited, but I can’t imagine they’ll run out just yet. I would think they’ll keep producing them for another year or so, while people still want them.
Can buy me love! Please consider supporting the Beatles Bible on Amazon
Or buy my paperback/ebook! Riding So High – The Beatles and Drugs
Don't miss The Bowie Bible – now live!
4.44pm
1 April 2010
Offline Hmm, yes, you’re probably right. Fingers crossed I can get a move on in time then. haha.
Do what you want to do, and go where you're going to…
12.03pm
10 May 2011
Offline MrBig said:
http://www.youtube.com/user/be…..oxset2009/
He's uploaded every song (in stereo and mono) and included the mini-docs. Badass.
A-G-R-E-E!
My Music Blog.
One and one don't make two
One and one make one.
12.05pm
10 May 2011
Offline 1 Guest(s)
