13 May 2014
Hey y'all. I'm an audio engineer and one of my favorite hobbies is to screw with Beatles tunes in digital editors because Beatles music is so clean and consistently mixed since the 2009 remasters. However, I've noticed something bizarre:
If you place the raw WAVE files for the Revolver 2009 stereo remaster of "Eleanor Rigby" and the Anthology 2 "strings only" versions in the same file, they initially sync up perfectly, as I would expect from Beatles recordings. However, the two tracks quickly fall noticeably out of sync and when looking at the end of the files, the two have a roughly one second difference. This has obvious implications regarding the quality of the tape playback during remastering (i.e. either it was slow for Anthology or fast for 2009 remasters).
Furthermore, when I compared the strings to the original CD stereo master of Revolver (American tracklisting circa 1980s), the same thing happened. I also compared the file lengths of the 2009 remaster and '80s original master (both stereo): 2009 is shorter than '80s master by about .08 seconds, though I assume this was to correct a mastering speed error introduced to the original CD master.
Given that both Revolvers have files with only negligible differences in length, I'm going to assume Anthology was mastered slow. Possible explanations I can think of are:
- The strings were originally recorded at that speed, but sped up slightly when the Beatles' overdubs were added, possibly to better match pitch
- There was a mastering error with the original LP, which recorded too fast and the "strings only" is the original recording speed
- There was simply a speed error when mastering Anthology, though this seems unthinkable with George Martin at the helm of the original equipment
But, I'd rather know than assume, so if anyone can shed some light, I would greatly appreciate it. And sorry that this is so verbose.
EDIT: Just want to clarify that by length, I mean from start of signal to end of signal, with all silence (~60dB and under) removed.
BTW, I searched the forum for this and found nothing. If I'm repeating an already-existing thread, kindly direct me there!
1 November 2013
I'm not hugely knowledgable here at all. In fact, I know nothing. I'd just like to welcome you and encourage you to stick around, introduce yourself, and have some discussions!
Oh, have you tried matching the Yellow Submarine Songtrack version? That's probably a different length seeing as it was remixed, but just a suggestion.
Most Users Ever Online: 597
Currently Online: Oudis
Currently Browsing this Page:
mr. Sun king coming together: 6916
Ahhh Girl: 5314
Mr. Kite: 3967
Ron Nasty: 3151
Guest Posters: 88
Newest Members: Anna555, BigSparklyEyes, nina555, mshearn3198, Phil74501
Moderators: Ahhh Girl: 5314, meanmistermustard: 10050, Zig: 4290, Joe: 3482
Administrators: Joe: 3482, Ellie: 1