Can we all agree … or not? | Page 18 | The songs | Fab forum

Please consider registering
Guest

Log In Register

Register | Lost password?
Advanced Search

— Forum Scope —





— Match —





— Forum Options —





Minimum search word length is 4 characters - maximum search word length is 84 characters

Can we all agree … or not?
31 May 2014
2.58pm
Annadog40
I am here you are here we are here and we are all together
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 6423
Member Since:
1 November 2013
Online
341

ahdn_paul_06 It could also depend on the people voting cause if their were ten of me voting then Piggies would be in the top ten.

Never say never, cause it's never 'never'

 

If you can't log in or can't access the forum, then head over to the unofficial back up forum and someone will help

31 May 2014
5.18pm
vonbontee
Inside a Letterbox
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2433
Member Since:
1 December 2009
Offline
342

Into the Sky with Diamonds said

@vonbontee [regarding the "Michelle" discussion above]

"Actually, I'd suspect the Grammys had more integrity in the mid-'60s! My chief complaint with them is that, for as long as I've been aware of them, they seem to regard huge record sales as the chief mark of greatness. How else to explain such timeless "Record of the Year" winners as Toto IV, Natalie Cole's Unforgettable, orThe Bodyguard soundtrack?"

Well doesn't that bolster the value of "Michelle"? It wasn't even released as a single, so it had zero record sales (except as part of Rubber Soul of course). If Grammy voters generally go with the big sales, they had to be REALLY be impressed with "Michelle" to vote it Song of the Year.

Again, this is not to say that the song deserves to be in our Top 10 or that our tastes have to mesh with Grammy voters of 50 years ago, but I'm surprised that such a classic has not even made it to the top half of our list. That's either a result of our small sample size or a sign that the song has not stood the test of time.

lol okay, fair enough, you've got me! You've turned me completely around…Call "Michelle's" nomination the exception that proves the rule! :D

I probably should have engaged your comments rather than just reacting instantly at the citation of the Grammy Awards. I think "Michelle" is mostly just great and would happily put it in the top, uhhh, 40. And in this case, I do appreciate the nomination under the terms you propose, in the same way I appreciate the enshrinement of "Yesterday" as a standard, and Frank Sinatra's famous endorsement of "Something". (Both of which are also Top 40 in my book.) Because all the appreciation from these "legitimate" tastemakers just illustrate this band's multifaceted greatness all the more.

The following people thank vonbontee for this post:

Into the Sky with Diamonds

Indian music can't be listened to the same way you hear rock and roll. You cannot do 'Yea Yea' and 'Go Man Go' - Ravi Shankar

31 May 2014
5.43pm
Annadog40
I am here you are here we are here and we are all together
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 6423
Member Since:
1 November 2013
Online
343

Where be the next rank results?

Never say never, cause it's never 'never'

 

If you can't log in or can't access the forum, then head over to the unofficial back up forum and someone will help

31 May 2014
5.50pm
Ron Nasty
"Where have you been?" "I'm not telling you..."
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 3687
Member Since:
17 December 2012
Offline
344

@Annadog40 Read post 338, on the previous page. It explains what has happened.

The following people thank Ron Nasty for this post:

Annadog40, IveJustSeenAFaceo
"I only said we were bigger than Rod... and now there's all this!" Ron Nasty
1 June 2014
7.25pm
Matt Busby
In the town where I was born
Candlestick Park
Forum Posts: 655
Member Since:
8 February 2014
Offline
345

If I'm not mistaken, with a sample size of 17, a single vote putting yesterday 92nd or lower would be enough to move it from #5 to #11. out of the top 10.  Probably nobody would put it that low, but a single vote of 21st would move it from 10 to 11 (thus out of the top 10).  Regardless, I suspect the 17 were mostly the big posters here, and I'm watching the thread just to get a sense of the beatlesbible "community" :)

 

EDIT:  Replaced 'nonetheless' with 'regardless'.  If any of you wonder why a lot of my posts are edited, it's because I always miss some little picky thing like that despite previewing it.

Half of what I say is meaningless...

Now I'm only 52 and all I wanna do is bugaloo

Help keep BeatlesBible alive! Use these links when shopping: Amazon | iTunes

13 June 2014
10.06pm
Bulldog
The Rhythm Revue
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 1511
Member Since:
3 June 2014
Offline
346

I just now checked the results that were in the results thread. Wow, some of it kind of offends me. Yes It Is, What You're Doing, One After 909, Matchbox, and Piggies are all much lower than I would have put them. They should at least be above... well, I don't know, but I think they all should have beaten Bad Boy. That song is pretty unremarkable in my opinion (the vocals are good, but... eh), and am I the only one that likes Slow Downa-hard-days-night-john-7 Probably.

Then again, when it comes to Beatles songs, almost any cut is difficult. At least Old Brown Shoe and I'm Down aren't out yet. a-hard-days-night-paul-5a-hard-days-night-george-3(Although they obviously won't either be in the Top 5, that's what I expect anyway.)

If you're lonely (or not!), you can talk to me. .....Hey! Are you a new member on this fine forum and don't know where to go to introduce yourself? Well, you can do it here! Dig it?
13 June 2014
10.53pm
Von Bontee
A Hole In The Road
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2467
Member Since:
14 December 2009
Online
347

WE CAN NOT AGREE

The following people thank Von Bontee for this post:

Bulldog, Annadog40, Beatleva
One day, a tape-op got a tape on backwards, he went to play it, and it was all "Neeeradno-undowarrroom" and it was "Wow! Sounds Indian!" -- Paul McCartney
14 June 2014
12.19am
Linde
The Netherlands
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2336
Member Since:
21 November 2012
Offline
348

Can we all agree to disagree then?

The following people thank Linde for this post:

Beatleva, trcanberra
14 June 2014
12.21am
Bulldog
The Rhythm Revue
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 1511
Member Since:
3 June 2014
Offline
349

a-hard-days-night-ringo-8Yup. 

If you're lonely (or not!), you can talk to me. .....Hey! Are you a new member on this fine forum and don't know where to go to introduce yourself? Well, you can do it here! Dig it?
14 June 2014
1.07am
vonbontee
Inside a Letterbox
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2433
Member Since:
1 December 2009
Offline
350

Linde said

Can we all agree to disagree then?

I can't agree to that! :D

(lol second time I've made that joke today! I always reply to that particular question in that fashion, even if I don't know what the context was. I overheard Jess saying it to Traci in the lunchroom when I arrived at work this morning and had to chime in.)

Indian music can't be listened to the same way you hear rock and roll. You cannot do 'Yea Yea' and 'Go Man Go' - Ravi Shankar

14 June 2014
1.11am
Annadog40
I am here you are here we are here and we are all together
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 6423
Member Since:
1 November 2013
Online
351

vonbontee roared hungrly 

Linde barked cat like

Can we all agree to disagree then?

I can't agree to that! :D

(lol second time I've made that joke today! I reply to that question in that fashion, even if I don't know what the context was.)

Them fightin' words

Never say never, cause it's never 'never'

 

If you can't log in or can't access the forum, then head over to the unofficial back up forum and someone will help

14 June 2014
1.39am
Linde
The Netherlands
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2336
Member Since:
21 November 2012
Offline
352

Bring it on!

20 July 2014
6.45pm
IveJustSeenAFaceo
Arrived Somewhere (But Not Here)
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2790
Member Since:
1 November 2013
Offline
353

GOOD NEW EVERYONE 

I managed to save almost all of my files, including the master copy! Now, I still don't have computer to put them on, but it's there! It will return! 

The following people thank IveJustSeenAFaceo for this post:

Annadog40, parlance, Ron Nasty, Ahhh Girl, Mr. Kite, Into the Sky with Diamonds

(This signature brought to you by Spaghetti Tuesdays. Occurring on Wednesdays since 2013.)

20 July 2014
6.59pm
Ron Nasty
"Where have you been?" "I'm not telling you..."
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 3687
Member Since:
17 December 2012
Offline
354

Any way to send to someone else, say meanmistermustard as I know he was helping, and get them to do the business for you?

The following people thank Ron Nasty for this post:

Annadog40
"I only said we were bigger than Rod... and now there's all this!" Ron Nasty
20 July 2014
9.32pm
meanmistermustard
Moderator



Forum Posts: 12354
Member Since:
1 May 2011
Offline
355

I'm happy to do whatever i can but its Faceo's project so if we are to wait until he has all together again then i'm happy with that too. I'm treating the break as one of those tv cliffhangers that you have to wait a year to find out what happened. I still haven't seen the last Christmas Doctor Who episode. 

The following people thank meanmistermustard for this post:

Annadog40, Mr. Kite
Don’t make your love suffer insecurities, trade the baggage of self to set another one free. ('Paper Skin' - Kendall Payne)
21 February 2015
7.53pm
IveJustSeenAFaceo
Arrived Somewhere (But Not Here)
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2790
Member Since:
1 November 2013
Offline
356

Remember, here's the thread where you discuss the rankings!

(This signature brought to you by Spaghetti Tuesdays. Occurring on Wednesdays since 2013.)

21 February 2015
8.36pm
Von Bontee
A Hole In The Road
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2467
Member Since:
14 December 2009
Online
357

Can't see the link

One day, a tape-op got a tape on backwards, he went to play it, and it was all "Neeeradno-undowarrroom" and it was "Wow! Sounds Indian!" -- Paul McCartney
21 February 2015
9.02pm
meanmistermustard
Moderator



Forum Posts: 12354
Member Since:
1 May 2011
Offline
358

The following people thank meanmistermustard for this post:

vonbontee
Don’t make your love suffer insecurities, trade the baggage of self to set another one free. ('Paper Skin' - Kendall Payne)
22 February 2015
12.32am
Atlas
Carnegie Hall
Forum Posts: 255
Member Since:
17 October 2013
Offline
359

Ron Nasty said

IveJustSeenAFaceo said

mja6758 said
There is no way Free As A Bird or Real Love can be considered a part of the canon. Every other Beatles recording released, including the BBC stuff, the Star Club recordings, the Tony Sheridan recordings, the Decca audition, and the archive Anthology material would come above those.

There is one simple reason, whatever anybody's personal feelings about them may be - negative or positive, they do not feature, and could not feature, the active participation of John. If this is to be done, it should be solely restricted to the core canon as settled in 1987 with the initial CD releases.

Above? I'd put them at least equal with them.

Above. John was not present, had no input, and no say on Free as a Bird or Real Love. I'm the Greatest or All Those Years Ago have more claim to being considered part of the canon. I'm sorry, the canon is what the group released while they were an ACTIVE band. Paul, George and Ringo overdubbing John demos was not The Beatles, whatever name you put it out under.

 

 

 I was listening to them recently and was staggered to discover, (after your assertion that John Lennon had 'no input' in these songs), that John had a hand in both of them….. it actually turns out that he wrote them and sang lead vocals……….

Mind you, if you don't think……overdubbing a lead vocal was something the Beatles routinely did in their recording career then that could explain your misconception of a word like 'input'.

The circumstances dictate that we cannot treat these two songs as normal Beatle recordings…..But it is the Beatles and I would argue John's creative input here is greater than many of the Beatle covers that he sang on.

 

You're entitled to your opinion of course ………..and I'm entitled to contest it.

22 February 2015
2.22am
meanmistermustard
Moderator



Forum Posts: 12354
Member Since:
1 May 2011
Offline
360

Lack of input to me means John could not at any point say if he wanted to change, adapt, remove, suggest, add etc any part of either 'Real Love' or 'Free As A Bird'. They were unfinished demo's, who knows what John had in mind for them as studio recordings - if anything. We have no idea if John would have said "fine, go with that as i don't want to be involved but do what you want with these two tracks Yoko thinks would work" or if he would have refused any part of a reunion or if he would have been fully involved. One of the biggest most important agreements the four Beatles had thru-out the 60's was that all four had to agree or at the very least not object to a release, if one didn't like it it didn't happen - a fundamental part of Paul's legal argument to split the Beatles up after Klein came in and became his manager (and Pul won). And on these John didnt and for all the want in the world Yoko is not John (and yes she is in control of John's estate as assigned by John before he died). Its not enough to say three Beatles + a demo of John's from 20 years ago = a full Beatles recording. Overdubbing onto a demo of someone's who is since dead is not even close to being the same thing as overdubbing a lead vocal whilst alive because if you are alive you have (more than likely) agreed to it.

I don't see how you can say @Atlas that you "would argue John's creative input here is greater than many of the Beatle covers that he sang on" as its not as, again, on those covers John agreed to record them and actively made suggestions on the musicianship and put his name to them, on these two reunion tracks he didn't as he couldn't. At least with 'Real Love' John worked on it frequently, with 'FAAB' he forget about it pretty quickly.

I am completely against these two songs being part of the same canon as all the songs released on the 12 UK albums from 'Please Please Me' thru to 'Let It Be', the US 'MMT' and the 1988 compilation 'Past Masters'.

On the same level as all the studio outakes and exclusive tracks performed for the BBC? I doubt it as once again on all of those John could contribute to what those tracks were they performed/recorded and their arrangements.  

I have no idea how you can say @Atlas that you "would argue John's creative input here is greater than many of the Beatle covers that he sang on" as its clealy not.

Don’t make your love suffer insecurities, trade the baggage of self to set another one free. ('Paper Skin' - Kendall Payne)
Forum Timezone: Europe/London

Most Users Ever Online: 597

Currently Online: Von Bontee, Wildcat, Annadog40, Merch, chrisredditch
58 Guest(s)

Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)

Top Posters:

meanmistermustard: 12354

Ahhh Girl: 7279

mr. Sun king coming together: 6931

parlance: 6663

Annadog40: 6421

Mr. Kite: 5601

Zig: 5461

mithveaen: 4633

Ron Nasty: 3687

fabfouremily: 2968

Member Stats:

Guest Posters: 88

Members: 3017

Moderators: 4

Admins: 2

Forum Stats:

Groups: 3

Forums: 34

Topics: 3363

Posts: 157776

Newest Members: systematicwalrus, daisylowe588, Ryde Ticket, Lend27, ednew

Moderators: Ahhh Girl: 7279, meanmistermustard: 12354, Zig: 5461, Joe: 3883

Administrators: Joe: 3883, Ellie: 1

Members Birthdays
Today: None
Upcoming: None