Log In
Register
Home
Topic RSS
2.12pm
10 August 2011
Offline
Henry the Horse,
Good post, welcome.
You're absolutely right. When minime (who started this thread) wrote "[songs] that others hate," I wondered, "who are the others?"
The others are simply the people around us – and we all have a different "us"
I've never heard anyone around "us" (me) hate "You Know My Name" because 99% of people around me have never heard of the song.
"Revolution #1" is also a forgotten song (among "us"), having been totally overshadowed by "Revolution" the single.
As for "Your Mother Should Know," I don't hear many people talk about it; but yes, among people who write articles and books, it usually fares poorly.
There's nothing wrong with the song itself. (In fact, it's fun to listen to a preliminary arrangement of the song on Anthology.) The problem is that it's not anything close to rock'n'roll or anything close to contemporary music. It sounded very old-fashioned ('20s, '30s) from the moment it appeared on the MMT album.
People put up with the similar sounding "When I'm 64" because it was Sgt Pepper, but with "Your Mother…" critics said, "what, again????"
1.32am
5 September 2012
Offline
Only a Northern Song, It's All Too Much and Blue Jay Way. Coincidentally, all George songs and they all have brilliant drums by Ringo! 
7.49am
8 August 2012
Offline
- Maxwells Silver Hammer: LOVED it when I was younger, love it still. Brings back so many memories. But the song is hated by almost everyone..
- Ob La Di Ob La Da: I know its a big hit, but seems like its a very disliked song aswell..
- I Want You/She's So Heavy: Many people think its a boring song, but I love it.
Thats all I could think of right now..
3.55pm
24 August 2012
Offline
I haven't been on this forum too long so I don't really know the opinions of others about what songs are generally disliked, but I personally am a huge fan of the White Album and Abbey Road.
One of my good friends can't deal with any of their psychedelic stuff, but I think it's incredible to get a glimpse into what the Beatles were thinking while they were writing this kind of music. So songs off of MMT especially are songs that I do like but I know someone who can't stand to listen to them.
My sister only likes their early stuff, but I wouldn't consider her to be a real fan anyways so it doesn't really count.
5.35pm
23 July 2012
Offline
Blue Jay Way, Maxwell's Silver Hammer, Run for your Life, It's All too Much…
I find I like a lot of Paul's piano-based "granny-music": Honey Pie, Your Mother Should Know, and I probably like Martha my Dear above all of them. 
5.42pm
3 May 2012
Offline
I can't really say that I hate any. Recently I have been listening to a lot of Paul's and George's songs from the White Album and surrounding albums.
6.13pm
24 August 2012
Offline
FlyOn13 said
Blue Jay Way, Maxwell's Silver Hammer, Run for your Life, It's All too Much…
I find I like a lot of Paul's piano-based "granny-music": Honey Pie, Your Mother Should Know, and I probably like Martha my Dear above all of them.
I absolutely love the granny music! I always find that if I'm ever in a bad mood I listen to Maxwell's Sliver Hammer (not for the words, obviously!), Ob La Di, Ob La Da, and the like. It definitely puts a smile on my face and makes my day better!
9.22pm
29 September 2012
Offline
Revolution 9 and What's the New Mary Jane. Many people just can't catch on to that avant-garde stuff.
9.31pm
3 May 2012
Offline
I appreciate how brilliant it is that just by listening to a composition, you can conjure up a picture in your mind. With 'Rev. 9', without knowing what it is about or the thought behind it, a lot of people that I know that have heard it have said to me, you know it sounds like a war or somehting similar. And then I tell them that the song is in actual fact called Revolution 9. That is great.
However, I have rarely sat through the full 8.32 minutes of Revoultion, I just can´t. Doesn´t mean I hate the song but I just don´t find it all that listenable. I don´t even know if ''song'' is the right word to describe it…
As for '(…) Mary Jane', well, I like it even less.
4.22am
3 September 2012
Offline
A lot of people bash everything George did before Revolver, or even up to the White Album and Abbey Road for some people. I personally really like You Like Me Too Much. I might just like it TOO much.. hah, well..
I agree with the Run For Your Life people as well. I listened to it for hours one day.. I could not stop.. It also seems like people hate their Decca Audition, or some songs specifically. I just love the whole thing.. I don't have much of an idea why, either.
3.14pm
15 September 2012
Offline
What's The New Maryjane doesn't get much love, and doesn't particularly deserve it, but the wordplay is humorous, and would have been a lot more welcome on 'The White Album' than Revolution No. 9
You Know My Name (Look Up The Number) is hilarious, has some great musical bits, was started in 1967 & revisited at various times for some tinkering by John and Paul before it was finally released when their partnership was eroding – plus it has a corny Brian Jones sax part which fits right in with it's overall bizareness
Misery lives up to its title for most listeners, but listening to the outtakes, when they're trying to nail the intro & then can't sing the right lyrics at the same time, makes me like it a bit more
I used to hate The Word, but started loving it when my oldies radio station began playing it
What Goes On used to grate on me a bit, but gets a pass for the very rare John/Paul/Ringo 3-part harmony
And Wild Honey Pie…
nope, still hate it
5.36pm
1 May 2011
Online
The only part of WTNMJ bareable is that piano part near the end, aside from that its incredibly irritating. At least with Revolution 9 you hear new bits every time you hear it, which admittedly is not very often.
Words of Love gets some criticism (Ian MacDonald slates it in Revolution in the Head) but i love the harmonies with John and Pauls singing and George's guitar. The live version they did for the bbc in '63 has a lot of charm.
12.08pm
23 September 2012
Offline
Not sure if people don't like Revolution 9 or if it is even classified as a song, but I love it so much because I find it so interesting. I used to think I was the bravest person listening to it at midnight when I was 10.
5.51pm
14 January 2013
Offline
Run For Your Life
Blue Jay Way
Revolution 9, I know I'm going to get flack for that because I said Wild Honey Pie is the worst because it doesn't make sense. I like it because of the whole Paul is dead bit. I suppose if I was alive in the 60s I would probably hate it thinking "what is this crap?"
Maxwell's Silver Hammer
Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da
Misery, I didn't know many people hate this one, but someone listed it above.
I am The Walrus
I Want You
Hold Me Tight
Love Me Do
Its All Too Much
6.02pm
8 November 2012
Offline
Learned in the past 2 weeks that Hold Me Tight is high on the list. ;->
parlance
8.14pm
10 February 2013
Offline
There are several of their songs I love that while not generally hated, are sometimes seen as throwaways. Paperback Writer and Birthday are the first that come to mind.
"Bad Boy" is one of the early(ish) covers that is usually overlooked or disliked, but I love it. John's vocal on it just cracks me up.
I also love "Free as a Bird." The video nearly always makes me tear up.
8.31pm
8 November 2012
Offline
Monkey Finger said
I also love "Free as a Bird." The video nearly always makes me tear up.
Yes, yes, same here. I don't know if I'd love it as much as I would if it weren't for the video. But as a child/teen of the 80s, I strongly associate music with videos, and quite often the images will have an impact on my perception of a song.
parlance
9.31pm
3 May 2012
Offline
Monkey Finger said
There are several of their songs I love that while not generally hated, are sometimes seen as throwaways. Paperback Writer and Birthday are the first that come to mind.I also love "Free as a Bird." The video nearly always makes me tear up.
I've never thought of 'Paperback Writer' as a throwaway. Why would they have put it out as a single rather than just an album track if they didn't think it was very good? I love it too though
There hasn't been one time when I've listened to 'FAAB' and not cried at the video. In fact, I only have to listen to the song and I'm in floods.
9.33pm
18 March 2013
Offline
I love "Within You Without You" and "The Inner Light" but my dad doesn't like indian-style music.
My Laptop:
Beatles Songs: 938 Solo Songs: 403
McCartney: 224 Lennon: 113 Harrison: 42 Starkey: 24
9.54pm
10 February 2013
Offline
I probably should have chosen a better word than "throwaway." You won't get any argument from me that it's a great record, it just seems to me that in most of the serious criticisms I've read, it usually gets short shrift, mainly because I think conventional wisdom is that it was a song written as one of those "oh, it's time for another single" type of thing. But it's got a killer riff, I love the harmonies, and I think the lyrics are clever.
"Hello Goodbye" is another one that usually isn't considered one of their more substantive songs, but I love the feel of it.
Most Users Ever Online: 597
Currently Online: meanmistermustard, Egroeg Evoli, AppleScruffJunior
3 Guest(s)
Top Posters:
mr. Sun king coming together: 6972
meanmistermustard: 3442
MeanMrsMustard: 2794
Egroeg Evoli: 1548
vonbontee: 1427
Von Bontee: 1380
Member Stats:
Guest Posters: 87
Members: 1687
Moderators: 5
Admins: 1
Forum Stats:
Groups: 3
Forums: 33
Topics: 2401
Posts: 73532
Newest Members: gibbonfunky, Jay Riley, BrettB, Ralphrennick, fartoons
Moderators: Joe (2702), skye (2295), Ellie (1), Zig (2752), mithveaen (4675)
Administrators: Joe (2702)
