A day in the life - Paul or John? | Page 17 | Fab Forum

Introducing the inaugural Fab Forum February Fundraiser! Click here for more details.

Please consider registering

sp_LogInOut Log In sp_Registration Register

Register | Lost password?
Advanced Search

— Forum Scope —

— Match —

— Forum Options —

Minimum search word length is 4 characters - maximum search word length is 84 characters

sp_Feed sp_TopicIcon
A day in the life - Paul or John?
This topic is locked No permission to create posts
3 August 2014
The Toppermost of the Poppermost

Forum Posts: 7584
Member Since:
14 April 2010
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Why do I always look like this when clicking on this miserable thread?

Image Enlarger

The following people thank Zig for this post:

Ahhh Girl, Mr. Kite, Silly Girl

To the fountain of perpetual mirth, Let it roll for all its worth.

Every Little Thing you buy from Amazon or iTunes will help the Beatles Bible if you use these links: Amazon | iTunes

5 June 2015
The Top Ten Club
Forum Posts: 60
Member Since:
29 April 2015
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

There's really no point in arguing this... Sgt. Pepper was the height of the Beatles' collaboration and teamwork, John/Paul grudges had not been formed yet, and it looked like The Beatles would last forever and their love would ultimately save the world as well as deliver countless songs for everyone to enjoy. The bubble burst the next year, and The Beatles became mostly a one-man-for-himself band, unfortunately, and the grudges took over. Now there is a civil war between John and Paul and suddenly every contribution from one onto the other's song (especially vocal) becomes a territorial battle.

I have always thought it was John because it just made sense that he sings a "lullaby" to Paul. If Paul sang it, I really wouldn't be surprised because he had the vocal range to comfortably hit the notes with all of the sustain (not that John couldn't either). Also, he could easily have altered his voice to sound more like John's (how many different voices did Paul have?). It's very possible that both did, but I haven't listened closely enough to tell if there is more than one voice. 

My point is that it does not matter who sang it (as long as it was a Beatle). Sgt. Pepper was the last true Beatle album, and we really do it a disservice by starting fights that don't belong in the context.

I am he as you are he and you are me and we are all together.

5 June 2015

Forum Posts: 17178
Member Since:
1 May 2011
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Annadog40 said
ahdn_paul_06 I think there was another thread about Paul vs George on bass I think that became heated.

Yip. I think thats the thread which ended with argument over charts and what you take from them - i think 'Michelle' (the song) was part of it. There have been a few.

Don’t make your love suffer insecurities, trade the baggage of self to set another one free. ('Paper Skin' - Kendall Payne)
5 June 2015
Somewhere In Time
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 1017
Member Since:
28 March 2014
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline
6 August 2015
A Beginning
Forum Posts: 7
Member Since:
6 August 2015
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Hi everybody, it's Michael, or, as most of you know me, paulsbass.

Hopefully just a short return since I don't want to go through all of this again, nor do YOU want this, I guess...

First let me say sorry for the messy way I ended my long membership of the BB-forum, taking all my posts with me. I was VERY frustrated with the way people who didn't know me AT ALL received my postings (hello ivejustseenherfaceo) or all the criticism I ALONE seemed to receive for this discussion - while it was very often very clearly the OTHER side who added aggression and heat (can't list them all correctly).

I NEVER wanted this controversy, and apart from saying "Nope, it's Paul" a few times too often I really can't see any major mistakes from my part here. I got stoned for being "unreasonable" because I wouldn't even "settle for a compromise", being "Paul AND John singing". Sorry, but why would I settle on that? Beatle fans of all people should know the sound of a double-tracked or doubled voice. The part in question is NOT doubled. And I didn't see how it was my mistake I was outnumbered in my opinion on this forum.

So I left, because I realized this place which I joined in high spirits so many years ago, thrilled by the idea of FINALLY being able to discuss my favourite band with other fanatics, had turned for me into a place which made me feel bad about myself and, even worse: Bad about the Beatles. Til this day I'm unable to enjoy one my favourite songs because of all the spite and venom I got from some people who - again - don't know me at all but still dare to judge me.

I know it's just the internet, and the day you start caring about Youtube- or Facebook-comments is a really bad one for you - still, after giving so much input that was often very much appreciated it hurt me to be turned into THE supervillain here - disregarding for example the very disturbing behaviour of one of my "infamous" discussion "foes" Mr. Big (ironically another German! I guess a lot of the controversy was caused just by bad grammar...), as if it was MY fault someone would consider George Harrison a better bass player than Paul, and vehemently so...

Anyway, I left, after talking things over with Joe. There's not a drop of bad blood there, for which I'm really grateful.

Sooo, long story short, why did I re-register, something I REALLY didn't want to do?

I tried very hard for the last year to get in contact withy anyone who is Paul or around him to get some "final statement" on the question.

That wasn't successful, but then I stumbled over this brilliant website "The Beatles Rarity" which I can highly recommend, even for BB-fans who are already quite well educated, thanks to Joe and his amazing work.

THE guy there is "Happy Nat" and he has an "ask Nat" section where you are allowed to post any Beatle-related question. You might quess what my question was...

Thankfully, after some time he came up with his take on the problem, and while it's not THE definitive "I told you so" Paul-statement that would shut up all doubts it's still a very nice sum-up of all the quotes and facts and it has the isolated vocals - AND Nat agrees with me, that these isolated vocals SHOULD end all discussions...


Well, as Nat expected, he didn't acchieve that, since it still depends on what you WANT to hear and we STILL don't have THAT final statement.

Anyway, I just wanted to take the chance to say "goodbye" a little more elaborately - and sorry for the controversy.

I STILL don't get why we have this discussion anyway!! 😉


7 August 2015
Forum Posts: 4392
Member Since:
31 March 2008
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Hi Michael. I'm glad to see you here again, though slightly less glad to see this thread brought back to life!

Everything in the past is water under the bridge as far as I'm concerned. As you say, there's no bad blood here.

Onto this subject, though. I'm glad that you and Happy Nat (Mark) found consensus. I disagree, however, when Mark says his audio sample "should put the debate completely to rest", "Paul's is without a doubt the more prominent [voice]" and that "his part is indisputable". It remains subjective, whichever way you cut it. Subjective is all well and good, but it should never be confused with empirical evidence.

I STILL don't get why we have this discussion anyway!! ??

Me neither, so let's not.

This subject will never have a resolution unless a) we get a definitive answer from someone who was there, or b) I force a resolution. To that end I'm locking this thread. If any new information emerges it can be opened up again, but opinions are not data.

Any new threads on this subject may be moved into this one, but the thread will remain locked until further notice.

Michael, please stay on the forum if you want to. Everyone's welcome as long as they're nice to one another. Just let's not discuss this subject, please...

Peace and love.

The following people thank Joe for this post:

This topic is locked No permission to create posts
Forum Timezone: America/Chicago

Most Users Ever Online: 597

Currently Online: pepperland, Annadog40, georgiewood, Merch, ewe2, Silly Girl, JPM-Fangirl
48 Guest(s)

Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)

Top Posters:

meanmistermustard: 17171

Ahhh Girl: 10762

Annadog40: 9782

Zig: 7567

parlance: 7092

mr. Sun king coming together: 6980

Mr. Kite: 6092

Silly Girl: 5846

trcanberra: 5550

Ron Nasty: 4952

Member Stats:

Guest Posters: 87

Members: 3336

Moderators: 4

Admins: 2

Forum Stats:

Groups: 3

Forums: 42

Topics: 3820

Posts: 202478

Newest Members:

Mercury7, babapez, tom_pw, beatlezoe, nicklav99

Moderators: Ahhh Girl: 10762, meanmistermustard: 17171, Zig: 7567, Joe: 4392

Administrators: Joe: 4392, Ellie: 3

Members Birthdays
Today: DrBeatle
Upcoming: None