Strawberry Fields and Penny Lane On Sgt Pepper? | Page 2 | Fab Forum

Please consider registering
Guest

sp_LogInOut Log In sp_Registration Register

Register | Lost password?
Advanced Search

— Forum Scope —






— Match —





— Forum Options —





Minimum search word length is 3 characters - maximum search word length is 84 characters

sp_Feed sp_TopicIcon
Strawberry Fields and Penny Lane On Sgt Pepper?
No permission to create posts
16 August 2013
5.52pm
Avatar
DrBeatle
Hershey via Boston
Candlestick Park
Forum Posts: 1541
Member Since:
29 November 2012
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

SFF and PL not ending up on Sgt. Pepper is one of those unintended strokes of luck that history is all the better for. Those songs are spectacular, of course, but not only would they have not fit in at all with the album (in terms of sentiment but also the overall sound) but Sgt. Pepper as we know it would be completely different and I'm not sure it'd be for the better.

"I know you, you know me; one thing I can tell you is you got to be free!"

 

Please Visit My Website, The Rock and Roll Chemist

Twitter: @rocknrollchem

Facebook: rnrchemist

 

16 August 2013
8.24pm
Avatar
fabfouremily
Sitting in an English garden
Rishikesh
Forum Posts: 2971
Member Since:
3 May 2012
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

I agree. There's something about the SSF/PL single that is magical in its own stand-alone way. Two songs, and yet so mind-blowing. Put them on Sgt. Pepper and not only do you further water down the concert vibe they were (perhaps half-heartedly) going for, but you also change the ''feel''- and importance - of the two songs themselves.

Moving along in our God given ways, safety is sat by the fire/Sanctuary from these feverish smiles, left with a mark on the door.

(Passover - I. Curtis)

16 August 2013
9.18pm
Avatar
Von Bontee
A Hole In The Road
Rishikesh
Forum Posts: 2843
Member Since:
14 December 2009
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

DrBeatle said

SFF and PL not ending up on Sgt. Pepper is one of those unintended strokes of luck that history is all the better for. Those songs are spectacular, of course, but not only would they have not fit in at all with the album (in terms of sentiment but also the overall sound) but Sgt. Pepper as we know it would be completely different and I'm not sure it'd be for the better.

One day, a tape-op got a tape on backwards, he went to play it, and it was all "Neeeradno-undowarrroom" and it was "Wow! Sounds Indian!" -- Paul McCartney
16 August 2013
9.22pm
Avatar
Von Bontee
A Hole In The Road
Rishikesh
Forum Posts: 2843
Member Since:
14 December 2009
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

See, that's where I disagree! I think many people would've learned to love the lp just as much if not more with those two. And then found it unimaginable without them. But YMMV I guess.

That Was a reply to Dr. Beatle, if it wasn't clear. Damned iPad kbd!

One day, a tape-op got a tape on backwards, he went to play it, and it was all "Neeeradno-undowarrroom" and it was "Wow! Sounds Indian!" -- Paul McCartney
16 August 2013
10.20pm
Avatar
Linde
The Netherlands
Rishikesh
Forum Posts: 2649
Member Since:
21 November 2012
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

I think so too. I also think the order of the songs doesn't matter. What does it matter if Within You Without You comes before Lovely Rita or after it or whatever?

It's hard to pick 2 tracks to dump though, and most of them wouldn't fit on MMT. With that having said, MMT wouldn't have been as good as it is without SFF and Penny Lane. They also fit on MMT much better than on Pepper. 

I always think MMT is a bit underrated. It's definitely one of my favourite Beatlesalbums. I mean come on, except for SFF and Penny Lane it has songs like I Am The Walrus, Fool on the hill, All You Need Is Love etc. All great songs. 

On the White Album subject though, I would have liked the single version of Revolution on it, but that's because I prefer it over Revolution 1. As for Hey Jude, I don't know if that would be good. It kind of fits the album, but at the same time it doesn't, if that makes sense. It's too big or something.

17 August 2013
12.00am
Avatar
Von Bontee
A Hole In The Road
Rishikesh
Forum Posts: 2843
Member Since:
14 December 2009
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

It's the removing I hate more than the altering! If Capitol had seen fit to include "Paperback Writer/Rain" on Revolver without removing the three John songs that found their way to "Yesterday and Today", I'd be delighted.

One day, a tape-op got a tape on backwards, he went to play it, and it was all "Neeeradno-undowarrroom" and it was "Wow! Sounds Indian!" -- Paul McCartney
17 August 2013
2.19am
Duke_of_Kirkcaldy
St. Paul, Minnesota, USA
London Palladium
Forum Posts: 180
Member Since:
24 August 2012
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Linde said
I think so too. I also think the order of the songs doesn't matter. What does it matter if Within You Without You comes before Lovely Rita or after it or whatever?

It's hard to pick 2 tracks to dump though, and most of them wouldn't fit on MMT. With that having said, MMT wouldn't have been as good as it is without SFF and Penny Lane. They also fit on MMT much better than on Pepper. 

Indeed, as John later said, take away the title track, its reprise and "With A Little Help From My Friends," and Sgt. Pepper is just another album of standalone songs in mostly random order.  I've never gotten this 'concert vibe' from it to which fabfouremily is referring.  And, unlike DrBeatle, I think the inclusion of SFF and PL would be for the better, since they're far and away better songs than any of the Paul songs that DID end up on the album.  (I'd have also put "Only A Northern Song" on there at the expense of one of those Paul songs as well.  [deflector shield up] ahdn_george_06)  I've actually put together my own preferred version of Sgt. Pepper as an iTunes playlist (ditto Let It Be), and it's the version to which I now usually listen.

It doesn't matter which 2 Sgt. Pepper castoffs (3 actually, since OANS also being on the album would've most likely returned "Baby, You're a Rich Man" to its original status as one of the 4 exclusive Yellow Submarine contributions) would have 'fit' onto MMT because that second side was an afterthought; whatever non-album songs were available were put on there.  Yes, it may have made MMT a weaker album (so to speak) today, but it would've strengthened Sgt. Pepper (and its reputation), IMO.

On the White Album subject though, I would have liked the single version of Revolution on it, but that's because I prefer it over Revolution 1. As for Hey Jude, I don't know if that would be good. It kind of fits the album, but at the same time it doesn't, if that makes sense. It's too big or something.

I don't see why "Hey Jude" wouldn't have fit on the White Album, as it turned out to be pretty much an 'anything-goes' sort of work, and it's that eclecticism that gives it its personality, IMO.  Take away the more tossed-off tracks like "Wild Honey Pie," "Why Don't We Do It In The Road??" and the "Can You Take Me Back" link between "Cry Baby Cry" and "Revolution 9" and it becomes a fairly rigid, straight-laced album.  That said, I'm perfectly fine with "Hey Jude" not being on it.

17 August 2013
10.39am
Avatar
Linde
The Netherlands
Rishikesh
Forum Posts: 2649
Member Since:
21 November 2012
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

I love that Can You Take Me Back bit between Cry Baby Cry and Revolution 9!

I think Hey Jude is just too long and spectacular to just end up as an album track. I think they made the right decision. Unless they put it both on the album and as a single.

19 September 2013
7.35am
kelandwood
A Beginning
Forum Posts: 5
Member Since:
18 September 2013
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

While those two songs would have fit very well on the album, there's nothing I really could bring myself to take off. It just doesn't feel right removing anything of it, because to me Sgt. Pepper as about as perfect as an album can get. What I think The Beatles should have done after Pepper, was do one last concert and turn it into a live album. Because as great as Sgt. Pepper is, the live feel that it tried to create only applied to a few of the songs and it didn't feel like a concert overall.

This is what the track listing would be, and I want to know if you guys can guess the story i'm trying to tell through these songs:

 

1. Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band

2. With A Little Help From My Friends

3. Strawberry Fields Forever

4. Penny Lane

5. Lovely Rita

6. Within You Without You

7. Tomorrow Never Knows

8. I Am The Walrus

9. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds

10. Yesterday

11. Getting Better

12. Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band (Reprise)

13. A Day In The Life

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

18 October 2015
10.29pm
Avatar
I was the walrus
The Cavern Club
Forum Posts: 77
Member Since:
21 July 2015
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

I agree that these two songs are better than some others on Pepper (Strawberry Fields being one of my all time favorites) but they definitely fit on MMT, not Sgt. Pepper.  

They wouldn't have gone with the flow of Pepper as much as the songs originally on it. 

19 October 2015
2.55am
Avatar
PokerMan
Junior's Farm
The Indra
Forum Posts: 41
Member Since:
15 May 2014
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

My preferred Sgt Pepper tracklisting:

 

1. Sgt Pepper

2. With A Little Help From My Friends

3. Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds

4. Getting Better

5. Only A Northern Song

6. She's Leaving Home

7. Penny Lane

8. Within You Without You

9. Strawberry Fields Forever

10. Lovely Rita

11. Good Morning Good Morning

12. Sgt Pepper (Reprise)

13. A Day In The Life

The following people thank PokerMan for this post:

trcanberra, Jojo McCartney, natureaker
19 October 2015
3.07am
Avatar
trcanberra
Oz
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 5776
Member Since:
29 August 2013
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

^ That's a rather nice looking album!

==> trcanberra and hongkonglady - Together even when not (engaged for those not in the know!) <==
No permission to create posts
Forum Timezone: America/Chicago

Most Users Ever Online: 597

Currently Online: Expert Textpert, Ahhh Girl, Starr Shine?, Evangeline, BeatlesNut, WeepingAtlasCedars
64 Guest(s)

Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)

Top Posters:

meanmistermustard: 18165

Ahhh Girl: 11578

Starr Shine?: 11240

Zig: 8150

Silly Girl: 7395

parlance: 7095

mr. Sun king coming together: 6980

Mr. Kite: 6132

trcanberra: 5776

Ron Nasty: 5282

Member Stats:

Guest Posters: 87

Members: 3456

Moderators: 4

Admins: 2

Forum Stats:

Groups: 3

Forums: 42

Topics: 3913

Posts: 215128

Newest Members:

Day Tripper, joe4, somethingsomething2, MartyMyDear, BeaCas

Moderators: Ahhh Girl: 11578, meanmistermustard: 18165, Zig: 8150, Joe: 4447

Administrators: Joe: 4447, Ellie: 3

Members Birthdays
sp_BirthdayIcon
Today: None
Upcoming: Caitie