Most underrated, and overrated song on Sgt. Peppers? | Page 3 | Sgt Pepper | Fab forum

Please consider registering
Guest

Log In Register

Register | Lost password?
Advanced Search

— Forum Scope —

  
 

— Match —

   

— Forum Options —

   

Minimum search word length is 4 characters - maximum search word length is 84 characters

Most underrated, and overrated song on Sgt. Peppers?
26 December 2012
5.41pm
Ben Ramon
Candlestick Park
Forum Posts: 619
Member Since:
26 March 2012
Offline
41

My favourite thing about When I'm Sixty-Four is that it comes after Within You Without You. Such a radical change in genres, from far-out philosophical Indian raga to cosy, twee English music hall- people who were listening for the first time in 1967 and thought the first side of the record was weird, would have surely been blown away by this double-punch on the second side!

 

 

The following people thank Ben Ramon for this post:

Mr. Kite
SHUT UP - Paulie's talkin'
26 December 2012
5.52pm
meanmistermustard
Moderator



Forum Posts: 11209
Member Since:
1 May 2011
Offline
42

I can honestly see some listeners in '67 scratching their heads and wondering what the heck was going on. Going from harps and a song about a girl running away from home to the fairground before heading into India and then a trip back to the music of yesteryear. Lovely Rita could be seen as safe ground yet the ending is incredibly random before heading to the world of animals barking, roaring and whatnot. Eventually it all ends with an unprecedented orchestral crescendo via a  song with scorching guitars but not quite because some weird gibberish has appeared that just wont shut up unless its turned off.

No wonder some reviewers slated it.

The White Album is said to be so scattergun with its musical genre's but Pepper is incredibly varied as well.

The following people thank meanmistermustard for this post:

Mr. Kite
Don’t make your love suffer insecurities, trade the baggage of self to set another one free. ('Paper Skin' - Kendall Payne)
28 January 2013
8.50pm
BBCSessions1963
Strawberry Fields
Royal Command Performance
Forum Posts: 122
Member Since:
28 January 2013
Offline
43

Most underrated: For me it's Getting Better, the guitar work is great and the tempo is light and sounds like a power flower great song! I don't hear it much on the radio as much as Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds or the song below that I think is the most overrated song on Sgt. Peppers

Most Overrated: A Day In Life. Sure it's a great song is one of my favorites infact its one of the first songs of The Beatles I listened too. It was something never done before and it was something never made before which is where it got it's praise. I like the song but its too overrated. 

And if you saw my love, I'll love her to.
28 January 2013
9.05pm
Beatles in the Blood
Nowhere Land
Hollywood Bowl
Forum Posts: 392
Member Since:
12 January 2013
Offline
44

BBCSessions1963 said
Most underrated: For me it's Getting Better, the guitar work is great and the tempo is light and sounds like a power flower great song! I don't hear it much on the radio as much as Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds or the song below that I think is the most overrated song on Sgt. Peppers

Most Overrated: A Day In Life. Sure it's a great song is one of my favorites infact its one of the first songs of The Beatles I listened too. It was something never done before and it was something never made before which is where it got it's praise. I like the song but its too overrated. 

 

Totaly agree on evrey thing there.

The Incedibly True Story THat Never Ends. By Sam.

Best Friend: WHat are you listening to

Me: The Beatles

Best Friend: Go Figure

29 January 2013
12.58am
Inner Light
Friar Park
Candlestick Park
Forum Posts: 524
Member Since:
20 December 2010
Offline
45

Over Rated Song: When I'm Sixty-Four

Under Rated Song: Within You, Without You

The further one travels, the less one knows
30 January 2013
12.47am
Egroeg Evoli
Across the universe
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 1664
Member Since:
6 December 2012
Offline
46

meanmistermustard said
I can honestly see some listeners in '67 scratching their heads and wondering what the heck was going on. Going from harps and a song about a girl running away from home to the fairground before heading into India and then a trip back to the music of yesteryear. Lovely Rita could be seen as safe ground yet the ending is incredibly random before heading to the world of animals barking, roaring and whatnot. Eventually it all ends with an unprecedented orchestral crescendo via a  song with scorching guitars but not quite because some weird gibberish has appeared that just wont shut up unless its turned off.

No wonder some reviewers slated it.

The White Album is said to be so scattergun with its musical genre's but Pepper is incredibly varied as well.

I agree.

 

Do you want to know a secret? Read my username backwards. ~ ~ ~ - - - . . . - - - ~ ~ ~ Also known as Egg-Rock, Egg-Roll, E-George, Eggy...

☮ & <3

31 January 2013
3.40am
LongHairedLady
coming in through the bathroom window
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2125
Member Since:
17 January 2013
Offline

Most overrated is definitely "Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds".  It's a good song, but I feel it gets more credit than it deserves.  Same goes for "With a Little Help from my Friends".

"A Day In The Life" deserves to be as popular as it is because it's an epic song, so not overrated in my opinion.

Underrated:  Fixing A Hole, She's Leaving Home, When I'm Sixty-Four, Lovely Rita.

"Please don't bring your banjo back, I know where it's been..  I wasn't hardly gone a day, when it became the scene..  Banjos!  Banjos!  All the time, I can't forget that tune..  and if I ever see another banjo, I'm going out and buy a big balloon!"

 

31 January 2013
1.30pm
Long John Silver
Hollywood Bowl
Forum Posts: 366
Member Since:
9 May 2012
Offline
48

It's the best song on the album after ADITL, so IMO it's definitely not overrated.

Living is easy with eyes closed, misunderstanding all you see.
31 January 2013
6.42pm
vonbontee
Inside a Letterbox
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2296
Member Since:
1 December 2009
Offline
49

It occurs to me how these underrated/overrated threads become more and more meaningless as the songs in question get cited more and more! (Well, the right songs, anyways.)

I just want to play. I’d like to think I could work opposite Sinatra, B.B. King, the Beatles, or a polka band... - Jazz musician Rahsaan Roland Kirk, 1967
31 January 2013
7.07pm
meanmistermustard
Moderator



Forum Posts: 11209
Member Since:
1 May 2011
Offline

Ringo's drumming on LITWD alone makes it one of the best songs on Pepper, throw in what everyone else is doing and its amazing. Even with everything isolated its a pure blast from start to finish. The Lowrey Organa-hard-days-night-ringo-6John's vocala-hard-days-night-ringo-6a-hard-days-night-ringo-6Some of the isolated tracks are incredible, the chimes and clarinets on When Im Sixty-Four are absolute class, minutes of undiluted joy.

Don’t make your love suffer insecurities, trade the baggage of self to set another one free. ('Paper Skin' - Kendall Payne)
7 December 2013
2.30am
Duke_of_Kirkcaldy
St. Paul, Minnesota, USA
Ed Sullivan Show
Forum Posts: 168
Member Since:
25 August 2012
Offline

I'd rank the songs as follows:

 1. "Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds"
 2. "Within You, Without You"
 3. "Good Morning, Good Morning"
 4. "A Day In The Life"
 5. "Being for the Benefit of Mr. Kite!"
 6. "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band"
 7. "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band (Reprise)"
 8. "When I'm Sixty-Four"
 9. "Getting Better"
10. "Fixing A Hole"
11. "With a Little Help from My Friends"
12. "She's Leaving Home"
13. "Lovely Rita"

I've made no secret around here that I'm not the biggest fan of Paul's contributions to the album, and this list should continue to reinforce that sentiment.  As far as most overrated, it's gotta be "She's Leaving Home."  I still can't get how this rather maudlin companion piece of sorts to "Eleanor Rigby" gets as much love as it does.  It's a good enough song (The Beatles were incapable of writing lousy songs  a-hard-days-night-paul-11), but come on.  The string & harp arrangement is almost sickeningly sweet, and the girl in the song has always struck me more as a typical stuck-up, self-absorbed teen than a victim of overly conservative parenting.  ahdn_paul_01  I'll also add "A Day In The Life" as being a bit overrated in that it nearly always ends up in the Top 5 of best Beatles song lists, whereas it barely makes my top 5 for just this album.  The most underrated song is definitely "Within You, Without You."  I know Indian music will always be an acquired taste to the vast majority of Westerners, but I have to laugh at those who claim this to be the all-time greatest rock album, yet they always skip Track #8 without fail.  a-hard-days-night-paul-3

8 December 2013
3.40pm
FizzleJayWay
London, UK
The Jacaranda
Forum Posts: 27
Member Since:
29 November 2013
Offline
52

I personally think When I'm Sixty Four is massively overrated I even learned it in school for singing assemblies maybe that contributed to my dislike towards the song. As for With A Little Help From My Friends I think it deserves it's recognition it's a damn good song same goes for A Day In The Life. Most underrated I agree Within You Without You for a long time I myself used to skip it then I properly listened to it and now it's one of my most played it's really unappreciated a-hard-days-night-ringo-8  

But if you want money for people with minds that hate... All I can tell you is brother you have to wait. Alright.

8 December 2013
8.41pm
Linde
The Netherlands
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2244
Member Since:
21 November 2012
Offline
53

meanmistermustard said
Ringo's drumming on LITWD alone makes it one of the best songs on Pepper, throw in what everyone else is doing and its amazing. Even with everything isolated its a pure blast from start to finish. The Lowrey Organa-hard-days-night-ringo-6John's vocala-hard-days-night-ringo-6a-hard-days-night-ringo-6Some of the isolated tracks are incredible, the chimes and clarinets on When Im Sixty-Four are absolute class, minutes of undiluted joy.

Yeah I've found that by listening to the isolated tracks, I've come to appreciate some songs a lot more. It makes me see what's so good about them even though I don't necessarily like some of them

5 February 2014
6.09pm
Bungalow Bob
Seattle, Washington
Hollywood Bowl
Forum Posts: 356
Member Since:
16 September 2013
Offline
54

I just read a random line from someone on the internet; I have no idea if she's speaking with any authority, but here's her quote: "Did you ever notice that the opening melodic line of "When I'm Sixty Four" is identical to the opening line of Wagner's "Ride Of The Valkyries?" Huh? Here's "The Ride Of The Valkyries;" I guess this person means the opening trumpet line at about 27 seconds, after the dramatic swirling strings intro. It's kind of a stretch, in my opinion. But it's good to possess such trivial knowledge; you never know when you might find yourself standing around at a stuffy, high society cocktail party, and you feel the need to say something interesting.

5 February 2014
7.59pm
xskelterhelterx
Nova Scotia
London Palladium
Forum Posts: 113
Member Since:
26 January 2014
Offline
55

overrated- when im 64/lsd

 

underrated- mr kite, Lovely Rita

5 February 2014
10.51pm
Atlas
Carnegie Hall
Forum Posts: 213
Member Since:
17 October 2013
Offline

Good point Bungalow Bob

 

It was one of Paul's earliest songs……..He was 14 when he wrote it……….... And his first instrument was a trumpet.

6 February 2014
4.49am
nzbeatlefan
New Zealand
London Palladium
Forum Posts: 107
Member Since:
5 February 2014
Offline
9 April 2014
12.04am
IrateMarauder
A Beginning
Forum Posts: 8
Member Since:
8 April 2014
Offline
58

Underrated-Within You Without You

Overrated- For The Benefit Of Mr. Kite

Yoko burned the rice again, ya know. 

https://www.youtube.com/user/edgeandy2jfan

9 April 2014
12.09am
Annadog40
I am here you are here we are here and we are all together
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 5483
Member Since:
1 November 2013
Offline
59

Overrated - Good Morning Good Morning

 

Underrated - Fixing A Hole

Never say never, cause it's never 'never'

If you are like a new thingy than introduction your self in the into place here

If you can't log in or can't access the forum, then head over to the unofficial back up forum and someone will help

9 April 2014
2.28am
Mr. Kite
910 Penny Lane, Strawberry Fields, Pepperland
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 5124
Member Since:
4 February 2014
Offline
60

I believe that while Within You, Without You is very underrated, we all respect and enjoy the song, so it's not completely disregarded. Being for The Benefit of Mr. Kite!, however, is barely even mentioned in what I've read of this topic, except IrateMarauder who surprisingly classified it as overrated. I don't think many casual fans have heard it or of it, and that for all work that went into it, cutting up the tapes and just how amazing it sounded at the end of it all, it isn't respected as much as some other great songs on this album. Right now I'm listening to just the left ear (as I tend to do) and its pretty much an instrumental, the part before the end is just put together so well and gives you the illusion you're at some odd dream carnival. That one part always reminds me of a dial tone and I imagine picking up a phone hearing that, and it starting to dance and make its own 'music' when the tone starts to shift. That's where my mind goes when I listen to that end part, and that's the best I can explain it. Great song, definitely underrated.

For overrated I'd have to go with Lucy. Love it obviously, but that's one of the Beatles songs everyone knows, it's got great music and imagery, but was made so popular and therefore overrated due to it spelling LSD. Its not the best of the ones everyone knows either, but it's held up there with them, so I'd say overrated.

And in any case, the whole album's filled with great stuff pretty much at the same level so to say whether or not its overrated I think we'd have to go with popularity in relation to creativity...

If I spoke prose you'd all find out, I don't know what I talk about.

Can buy Joe love! If you're shopping at one of these two websites use the links below to support the Beatles Bible: Amazon | iTunes
Forum Timezone: Europe/London

Most Users Ever Online: 597

Currently Online: georgiewood, Brandy12356
44 Guest(s)

Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)

Top Posters:

meanmistermustard: 11209

mr. Sun king coming together: 6919

Ahhh Girl: 6248

parlance: 5927

Annadog40: 5483

Mr. Kite: 5124

Zig: 4875

mithveaen: 4633

Ron Nasty: 3410

fabfouremily: 2951

Member Stats:

Guest Posters: 88

Members: 2810

Moderators: 4

Admins: 2

Forum Stats:

Groups: 3

Forums: 34

Topics: 3281

Posts: 147441

Newest Members: Brandy12356, Goodfinger, claptonlennon, ThatOneBeatlesFan, stuartswift

Moderators: Ahhh Girl: 6248, meanmistermustard: 11209, Zig: 4875, Joe: 3726

Administrators: Joe: 3726, Ellie: 1

Members Birthdays
Today: None
Upcoming: None