Topic RSS
1.42am
5 November 2011
OfflineIn this thread, I will list what I feel to be Paul's best bass performances, along with some brief justification for these views. This isn't a "top 10" or "top 5" list; I will only list those songs I feel to be in the "top-rank," with no particular care about how many that comes to.
What makes for a "great" McCartney bass riff? I think it has to come from Paul's distinctive and unique style, and not from instances where he is being derivative (copying the style of others). Paul's distinctive style of bass playing could also serve as predicates for McCartney himself as a person; McCartney is at his best when his bass playing is moody, bi-polar, and restless. In a sense, I think it can be argued that Paul really isn't fully himself as an artist outside of some of his most honest and fully realized bass lines. With that said, here is my list of the finest Paul bass performances (with the Beatles):
- Hey Bulldog – This is, in my opinion, his best. Especially pay attention to his riffing starting at 2:12. The whole song, however, is masterfully moody and expressive.
- Sexy Sadie – Without Paul, this one would have been a real snoozer. McCartney's bass is what makes this one truly fascinating.
- Being for the Benefit of Mr.Kite – Goes from brilliantly menacing to whimsical with plenty of other moods in between. The middle part of this song would be a complete disaster were it not for Paul's incredibly interesting bass line. Again, this probably wouldn't even be a very good song without McCartney. But with McCartney and Lennon together, it's an artistic triumph.
- I want you (She's so heavy) – McCartney's bass is the only reason to listen to this one, but that's a very good reason. The guitar and vocal melodies in the "She's so heavy" part are good too, though.
- With A Little Help From My Friends – Lots of creative little diversions. Gives the song its soul. As usual, McCartney's bass is the melodic and emotional "center" of the Beatles.
- Rain – This one is really interesting, I think, because it's right on the cusp of McCartney really coming into his own as an artist and as a bass player. He's starting to find himself in this one, I think.
- You're Going to Lose that Girl – This one is sort of like Rain: interesting from the standpoint of McCartney's development as an artist. This is one of the first songs where he really seems to start experimenting and being more adventurous and ambitious.
- Something – Whimsical and creative. Steals the show. Great one.
- Dear Prudence – Paul takes awhile to warm up in this one, but when he does he delivers one of his classics. I think a strong argument could be made that this is his best. Very mature, unusual, and surprising. Very experimental tonally, but in a pure and honest manner (i.e. without resorting to a lot of special effects). Can't praise this one enough.
- Taxman – I put this one in with Rain. I think this one is a sign of things to come. Some see this as perhaps his best performance, and it's certainly a very impressive piece of playing both technically and creatively. But I still see this as a great but transitional piece of playing. It's still somewhat derivative: it's more like "McCartney playing Motown" than a truly pure Paul McCartney piece.
1.55am
1 May 2011
Offline3.48am
1 May 2010
OfflineInteresting list. Ian Macdonald (author of Revolution In The Head) thought the bass part on Something was misjudged and too busy, and I think I agree with him. I'd add Lucy In The Sky to the list too. Interesting that most of the songs are primarily Lennon's, none sung by McCartney.
3.13pm
16 February 2011
OfflineJoe said:
Interesting list. Ian Macdonald (author of Revolution In The Head) thought the bass part on Something was misjudged and too busy, and I think I agree with him. I'd add Lucy In The Sky to the list too. Interesting that most of the songs are primarily Lennon's, none sung by McCartney.
If you would have read their other thread, you would wonder no more…
3.59pm
23 January 2011
OfflineJoe said:
Interesting list. Ian Macdonald (author of Revolution In The Head) thought the bass part on Something was misjudged and too busy, and I think I agree with him. I'd add Lucy In The Sky to the list too. Interesting that most of the songs are primarily Lennon's, none sung by McCartney.
I think it's true that the McCartney was able to focus more on innovative bass lines when he wasn't having to worry about the overall structure of the song. This point has been made before, by some critic…can't remember which.
4.11pm
12 March 2010
Offline6.55pm
20 September 2011
Offlinemithveaen said:
You forgot Helker Skelter.
You're poking the troll…apples for you.


9.53pm
1 December 2009
Offline9.57pm
1 May 2010
Offline10.35pm
12 March 2010
Offlinevonbontee said:
Can I just say that everytime paulsbass types "Mr. Anderson" I mentally hear Agent Smith addressing Neo?
LOL! Where do you think I got the inspiration from!
Agent Smith was by far the coolest character in the whole Matrix series, and his "Mr. Anderson" always brought cheers from the audiences when it was repeated in movie 2 and 3.
I was thinking about making a similar offer to "our" Mr. Anderson:
"I see two possible personalities for you: One is an arrogant, patronizing jerk. The other is an intellectual but still emotionally engaged and nice Beatle fan.
One of these personalities has a future.
The other one has not."
Ok, it's not as cool as the original, and it would kind of make him the "ONE", so I didn't do it…
10.45pm
1 December 2009
Offline11.27pm
20 September 2011
OfflinePaulsbass, I love you.


from a Matrix fan.
4.54am
10 August 2011
OfflineI agree completely with "Hey Bulldog," "Something," "With a Little Help…"
(see http://www.intotheskywithdiamo…..NGS_2.html)
I would put "Nowhere Man" in the top 5.
Thanks, I'll check out the others. (Never noticed the bass on "Sexy Sadie" or "You're Gonna Lose …!)
4.55pm
20 December 2010
Offline8.23pm
1 May 2010
Offline10.48pm
20 December 2010
Offlinemithveaen said:
Umb.. really? Can you tell me a song where Paul's bass impressed you in that album? I hadn't paid attention to that..
I like 'I Saw Her Standing There' & 'Boys' the most. You can really hear his bass well if you have the remastered stereo versions.
When he took over the bass when Stuart passed away, it was a perfect transition. After all, he is the bass player for the Beatles.
5.55am
1 May 2010
Offline10.25pm
24 October 2011
Offline11.26pm
23 November 2011
OfflineHard to tell what is a good Paul bass without reference to Ringo and John's playing -- at least in the earlier times. Paul's base may or may not be "great" depending on what the others are doing since they formed a wonderful rhythm section, something I don't hear mentioned much, the three of them making your feet dance.
I would like to see a discussion of John's rhythm playing since it seems to play a huge part in all this. Or, I think it's John's playing. Like, "I'm Happy Just to Dance with You" and many others. Someone is working very hard on this rhythm. I assume it's not George, but I can't know (I don't know enough). This is not their best rhythm, but the guitar work is clear -- perhaps too busy, really. Oh, well.
Most Users Ever Online: 597
Currently Online: LongHairedLady
55 Guest(s)
Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)
Top Posters:
mr. Sun king coming together: 6972
meanmistermustard: 3545
MeanMrsMustard: 2794
Egroeg Evoli: 1630
vonbontee: 1427
Von Bontee: 1397
Member Stats:
Guest Posters: 87
Members: 1728
Moderators: 5
Admins: 1
Forum Stats:
Groups: 3
Forums: 33
Topics: 2433
Posts: 74706
Newest Members: jonnblaze, ZadeImHi, HiImZade, ThomRoxeb1, Mary Gaspard Mcmillan
Moderators: Joe (2707), skye (2295), Ellie (1), Zig (2769), mithveaen (4675)
Administrators: Joe (2707)
Log In
Register
Home





*zigs with coffee*



