Paul v.s. George on Lead Guitar | Page 3 | Paul McCartney | Fab forum

Please consider registering
Guest

Log In Register

Register | Lost password?
Advanced Search

— Forum Scope —

  

— Match —

   

— Forum Options —

   

Wildcard usage:
*  matches any number of characters    %  matches exactly one character

Minimum search word length is 4 characters - maximum search word length is 84 characters

Paul v.s. George on Lead Guitar
3 March 2014
7.15am
markburgle
A Beginning
Forum Posts: 6
Member Since:
6 February 2014
Offline
41

Does anyone know who played what on She Came In Through The Bathroom Window? Paul AND George are credited with lead, so at first I thought maybe Paul did the answering riffs in the verses and George did the other more jammy stuff. However I don't think those parts overlap at all, and they sound like they could be the same guitar track, sound wise.

Somehow, given how much Paul was dominating (especially on his own stuff), it would make me happy if those answering phrases are Georges. They really make the song

3 March 2014
7.57am
Ron Nasty
"Where have you been?" "I'm not telling you..."
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 3034
Member Since:
17 December 2012
Offline
42

@markburgle While not being able to be precise on who played what bit, I can help with the way it was recorded – which offers some direction as to who played what. Bathroom Window was recorded along with Polythene Pam beginning on the 25 July 1969 (the two songs being recorded as one track, rather than edited together later – so it's Polythene Pam/She Came In Through The Bathroom Window). On that day they recorded, over 39 takes, the basic track. That consisted of Paul on bass, George on lead, John on acoustic, Ringo on drums, with guide vocals from John and Paul where appropriate. The only survivors from this basic track were George's lead and John's acoustic.

There seems to have been a problem with Ringo's drumming (John complaining that it "sounds like Dave Clark!"). Before the day was out, drums, bass, and vocals would be replaced.

On the 26 July they made various overdubs, another lead vocal, acoustic and electric guitars, various bits of percussion including tambourine, and an electric and normal piano.

More vocals, percussion and guitar were added on 30 July, the day the first rough version of the medley was put together.

So, the basic lead guitar part is definitely George. Were I to guess, I would suggest that both may have overdubbed bits on 26, while Paul alone would have done the last bits he wanted on 30. That is just a guess though.

 

"I only said we were bigger than Rod... and now there's all this!" Ron Nasty
3 March 2014
3.56pm
LikeASir
Ed Sullivan Show
Forum Posts: 177
Member Since:
29 August 2013
Offline

If I remember correctly, wasn't George pissed off how on Taxman he spent ages trying to make the solo then Paul just came in and improvised the whole thing? Or am I just entering the realms of fantasy here? paul-mccartney

 http://afloydianslip.tumblr.com/

"White Album - My joint-fave Beatles album along with Revolver. They show the two sides of Beatles. Revolver's very controlled - even though it's also very innovative. The White Album's playful and almost ramshackle. It's like a scrapbook kept by a genius. Fantastic stuff."

3 March 2014
7.47pm
Inner Light
Friar Park
Shea Stadium
Forum Posts: 495
Member Since:
20 December 2010
Offline
44

I really don't think George would not have been able to do a guitar solo for Taxman no matter what Emmerick say's in his book.

He was pro Paul anyway. I think he was nice enough to let Paul do a little solo in one of his songs and he even said that Paul did a little Indian bit for him in Taxman

I would say that any guitar solo in a Beatles song that sounds complicated, George probably played it. That is how proficient he was on the guitar. 

 

The further one travels, the less one knows
3 March 2014
9.23pm
IveJustSeenAFaceo
Somewhere other than where you are.
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2616
Member Since:
1 November 2013
Offline
45

Inner Light said
I really don't think George would not have been able to do a guitar solo for Taxman no matter what Emmerick say's in his book.

He was pro Paul anyway. I think he was nice enough to let Paul do a little solo in one of his songs and he even said that Paul did a little Indian bit for him in Taxman

I would say that any guitar solo in a Beatles song that sounds complicated, George probably played it. That is how proficient he was on the guitar. 

 

I'm fairly sure Lewisohn mentions the same thing as Emerick (I'm not sure though, anyone?). And I'm fairly sure George wouldn't have let Paul take the solo on his song, unless he really really couldn't nail it.

(This signature brought to you by Winter. Coming for an abnormally long amount of time.)
3 March 2014
10.12pm
vonbontee
Inside a Letterbox
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2216
Member Since:
1 December 2009
Offline
46

LikeASir said

If I remember correctly, wasn't George pissed off how on Taxman he spent ages trying to make the solo then Paul just came in and improvised the whole thing? Or am I just entering the realms of fantasy here? paul-mccartney

I don't think that solo was improvised – it sounds too nicely composed to be a one-off. In fact, I've long believed that the backwards-guitar solo in "Tomorrow Never Knows" is actually assorted snippets from Paul's (George's??) earlier attempts at a "Taxman" solo.

I just want to play. I’d like to think I could work opposite Sinatra, B.B. King, the Beatles, or a polka band... - Jazz musician Rahsaan Roland Kirk, 1967
6 March 2014
11.05pm
markburgle
A Beginning
Forum Posts: 6
Member Since:
6 February 2014
Offline
47

mja6758 said
@markburgle While not being able to be precise on who played what bit, I can help with the way it was recorded – which offers some direction as to who played what. Bathroom Window was recorded along with Polythene Pam beginning on the 25 July 1969 (the two songs being recorded as one track, rather than edited together later – so it's Polythene Pam/She Came In Through The Bathroom Window). On that day they recorded, over 39 takes, the basic track. That consisted of Paul on bass, George on lead, John on acoustic, Ringo on drums, with guide vocals from John and Paul where appropriate. The only survivors from this basic track were George's lead and John's acoustic.

There seems to have been a problem with Ringo's drumming (John complaining that it "sounds like Dave Clark!"). Before the day was out, drums, bass, and vocals would be replaced.

On the 26 July they made various overdubs, another lead vocal, acoustic and electric guitars, various bits of percussion including tambourine, and an electric and normal piano.

More vocals, percussion and guitar were added on 30 July, the day the first rough version of the medley was put together.

So, the basic lead guitar part is definitely George. Were I to guess, I would suggest that both may have overdubbed bits on 26, while Paul alone would have done the last bits he wanted on 30. That is just a guess though.

 

cheers for the input, my suspicion is that Paul did those answering riffs, they seem a bit perky/poppy for George at that point

7 March 2014
2.05am
Musketeer Gripweed (kezron9)
Coldspring Harbor, NY
Carnegie Hall
Forum Posts: 208
Member Since:
17 January 2014
Offline
48

markburgle said
Does anyone know who played what on She Came In Through The Bathroom Window? Paul AND George are credited with lead, so at first I thought maybe Paul did the answering riffs in the verses and George did the other more jammy stuff. However I don't think those parts overlap at all, and they sound like they could be the same guitar track, sound wise.

Somehow, given how much Paul was dominating (especially on his own stuff), it would make me happy if those answering phrases are Georges. They really make the song

Hey, I know on the anthology version at the end Paul is talking to someone either John or George about the guitar arrangement.  He mentions that he liked the nice bit like an oldie, one of them did. Check it out it might be the sequence you are talking about. A much slower version from the 3rd anthology believe disc 1. 

7 March 2014
2.38am
meanmistermustard
Moderator



Forum Posts: 9776
Member Since:
1 May 2011
Online
49

kezron9 said

markburgle said
Does anyone know who played what on She Came In Through The Bathroom Window? Paul AND George are credited with lead, so at first I thought maybe Paul did the answering riffs in the verses and George did the other more jammy stuff. However I don't think those parts overlap at all, and they sound like they could be the same guitar track, sound wise.

Somehow, given how much Paul was dominating (especially on his own stuff), it would make me happy if those answering phrases are Georges. They really make the song

Hey, I know on the anthology version at the end Paul is talking to someone either John or George about the guitar arrangement.  He mentions that he liked the nice bit like an oldie, one of them did. Check it out it might be the sequence you are talking about. A much slower version from the 3rd anthology believe disc 1. 

Disc 2. Disc 1 ends on Julia.

"Well, probably we'll sell less records, less people'll go to see the film, we'll write less songs, and we'll all die of failure" (John Lennon 8/64)
8 March 2014
2.53am
acmac
Carnegie Hall
Forum Posts: 231
Member Since:
1 August 2013
Offline

Inner Light said
I agree with the commercial aspect of McCartney's songs. He definitely wrote songs that would fit that genre. Harrison and Lennon wrote songs they wanted to write and weren't focused on whether or not they would become hits or not. An artist needs to express their thoughts and feelings when writing compositions. I know in the beginning, they had a formula they used which turned out a lot of hits but as time progressed, the songs became more sophisticated and everything changed on how they wrote. They wrote for themselves and not just trying to pump out a hit song. McCartney has always been the showman of the Beatles and of course Ringo has become more of a showman over the years also. A talent is in the eyes of the beholder. Personally, I will take an artist that writes and speaks from their heart over anyone who just writes songs to sell it and play the game of commercialism.

I think it's pretty harsh to say Paul doesn't write from his heart and just tries to pump out hits and play the game of commercialism.

I'll agree that George's music was more consistent, and much more tightly centered around the things most important to him -- and I totally get why many people would find that more appealing in an artist! But Paul has surely written just as many, just as meaningful, songs from the heart. Songs that resonate deeply with the hearts of his fans. Those hearts may be a different shape than yours, but that doesn't mean they ain't there.

The main difference I think is that Paul doesn't use music to express "important" things exclusively. He uses music for everything. It's his escape, his distraction, his addiction, medicine, pet, anchor, toy, teacher, friend, and hairbrush. A very necessary channel for his excess energy. Appetizer, entree, and dessert. I don't think he can help himself. I don't think he would if he could. He is probably a little bit crazy. One day he may snap and start walking around speaking in song. Sometimes he walks a fine line with that, as it is. He is frequently awkward and embarrassing. That doesn't cancel out his genius -- nor do his failures cancel out his triumphs. Breadth and depth are not mutually exclusive. 

8 March 2014
3.09am
acmac
Carnegie Hall
Forum Posts: 231
Member Since:
1 August 2013
Offline

IveJustSeenAFaceo said
I'm fairly sure Lewisohn mentions the same thing as Emerick (I'm not sure though, anyone?). And I'm fairly sure George wouldn't have let Paul take the solo on his song, unless he really really couldn't nail it.

I imagine it was more a bout of writer's block (guitarist's block?) than finger failure or whatever. Like, he was too deep into it to work out the last piece of the puzzle to his own satisfaction. It's a pretty common creative phenomenon, isn't it; everything's there except the title, or the refrain, or the character's name. Decision fatigue probably has something to do with it. So that's when an objective third party can really come in handy.

8 March 2014
3.23am
Atlas
Ed Sullivan Show
Forum Posts: 166
Member Since:
18 October 2013
Offline
52

I like George's stuff……….. But over the years I've discovered that some of the best things I thought he did…….he didn't!!

8 March 2014
3.35am
IveJustSeenAFaceo
Somewhere other than where you are.
Apple rooftop
Forum Posts: 2616
Member Since:
1 November 2013
Offline
53

acmac said

IveJustSeenAFaceo said
I'm fairly sure Lewisohn mentions the same thing as Emerick (I'm not sure though, anyone?). And I'm fairly sure George wouldn't have let Paul take the solo on his song, unless he really really couldn't nail it.

I imagine it was more a bout of writer's block (guitarist's block?) than finger failure or whatever. Like, he was too deep into it to work out the last piece of the puzzle to his own satisfaction. It's a pretty common creative phenomenon, isn't it; everything's there except the title, or the refrain, or the character's name. Decision fatigue probably has something to do with it. So that's when an objective third party can really come in handy.

Funny you mention that, I worked out a song a few weeks ago, but I just could not figure out a chorus that worked. Then I discovered I'd accidentally pilfered the main riff from a One Direction song, and that was the end of that.

The following people thank IveJustSeenAFaceo for this post:

acmac
(This signature brought to you by Winter. Coming for an abnormally long amount of time.)
23 March 2014
5.18pm
acmac
Carnegie Hall
Forum Posts: 231
Member Since:
1 August 2013
Offline
54

IveJustSeenAFaceo said
Funny you mention that, I worked out a song a few weeks ago, but I just could not figure out a chorus that worked. Then I discovered I'd accidentally pilfered the main riff from a One Direction song, and that was the end of that.

LOL! That's awesomely hilarious.a-hard-days-night-paul-10

23 March 2014
9.32pm
Musketeer Gripweed (kezron9)
Coldspring Harbor, NY
Carnegie Hall
Forum Posts: 208
Member Since:
17 January 2014
Offline
55

That is funny. Yeah I am actually having trouble with the chorus of a song I was working on. Then it popped into my head when I was watching a movie at a friends, left to rush home and finish. Love working on music think I am going to leave it as an acoustic ballad and a solo song. Maybe it can be my yesterday lol. Just played a side set at SXSW with band, and did a two week west coast tour. 

Forum Timezone: Europe/London

Most Users Ever Online: 597

Currently Online: meanmistermustard, Ahhh Girl, CheerDown783
44 Guest(s)

Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)

Top Posters:

meanmistermustard: 9776

mr. Sun king coming together: 6916

parlance: 5109

Ahhh Girl: 4964

mithveaen: 4651

Annadog40: 4163

Zig: 4100

Mr. Kite: 3696

Ron Nasty: 3034

fabfouremily: 2934

Member Stats:

Guest Posters: 88

Members: 2595

Moderators: 4

Admins: 2

Forum Stats:

Groups: 3

Forums: 34

Topics: 3159

Posts: 134149

Newest Members: CheerDown783, Nereus, Mazza, AllMyLoving, KenO

Moderators: Ahhh Girl (4964), meanmistermustard (9776), Zig (4100), Joe (3452)

Administrators: Joe (3452), Ellie (1)

Members Birthdays
Today: None
Upcoming: None