1 December 2009
1 May 2011
The Beach Boys record label threatened Katy Perry, or her representatives, with legal action over her single 'California Girls' as they felt it was synonymous with their own song and that one of the lines was very similar to the other. Barmy to say the least. There are too many laywers and executives in the music business who are only interested in making a buck. Apple are great at issuing legal action at the merest hint of beatle copyright being used infringed. Its one thing to protect your interests but not to the point of killing creativity. The beatles were always stealing melodies, chords and lyrics from other artists.
14 December 2009
I agree with vonbontee. It's all about "My sweet lord/Oh my lord" versus "He's so fine/Wish he were mine". Also, the melody of the doo-lang-doo-lang vocals aren't dissimilar from the repeated "Hallelujah/Hare rama" etc. I bet Spector knew about the similarity all along, even if Harrison had forgotten about the Chiffons' song.
15 May 2014
Does anybody know anything about George’s reaction to the accusation of plagiarism? Did he ever say anything to the press, make any statement? I’d like to know how he felt about the whole thing. I guess it must have been tough for him.
"For in my nature I quested for beauty, but God, God hath sent me to sea for pearls." (from Jubilate Agno by Christopher Smart)
17 October 2013
He nicked it……. It's a shame and a real blot on his reputation. He did so much good stuff of his own……but it just makes you wonder what else he pinched.
There're lots of 'ripped off song compilations' on you tube……..Beach Boys and Chuck Berry etc……...
To add something new I've always though Rufus Thomas' 'Walking the Dog' and Jimi Hendrix's 'Purple Haze' have some things in common.
The following people thank Atlas for this post:Oudis
19 April 2010
It seems impossible to me that whether George realized the similarities at first or not when he first wrote it, that by the time they were playing it, arranging it, recording it, mixing it, etc - especially with Phil Spector there, and the Beatles having noted the Chiffons as among their favorite girl groups, plus add the inside joke of "My Sweet Lord - He's so Fine" there is NO WAY someone didn't bring it to George's attention - and either they blew it off or thought it might worth the publicity.
IN 1980 Lennon is quoted as saying "[George] walked right into it. He knew what he was doing...[he] could have changed a few bars in that song and nobody could have ever touched him, but he just let it go and paid the price. Maybe he thought God would just sort of let him off."
By the time the song came George knew - it's my opinion - but I think it's what happened.
The following people thank robert for this post:Oudis
1 May 2011
If you say that its a shame on his repution @Atlas then surely the same applies to the Beatles (who nicked stuff from all over the place), John, who even got sued and had to record three tracks as recompense over his use of "Here comes old flat-top", and every artist who's ever done such a thing as it happens all the time in music. One of The Verve's best know hits 'Bittersweet Symphony' was based so much on an instrumental version of The Rolling Stones 'The Last Time' that they didnt bother with the court case instead just handing over 100% of the song-writing royalties. Some get away with it others dont.
As for George's reaction to it all, he got fed-up with the court case, which dragged on for years and is as complicated as complicated can be (Allen Klein plays a huge part), and sick with the taste of it all but drew some solace in the knowledge that the track brought and meant so much to so many people. He eventually re-recorded it for the 'All Things Must Pass' Reissue in 2000.
I'd heartily recommend anyone interested in the whole debacle listen to Fab4Free4All's podcast episode on the coutcase - 'My Sweet Lawsuit' - for all the details (scroll down the linked page to episode #55 or find it on itunes). I've listened to it twice and still find it confusing.
The following people thank meanmistermustard for this post:Zig, Oudis
14 April 2010
If you say that its a shame on his repution @Atlas then surely the same applies to the Beatles (who nicked stuff from all over the place), John, who even got sued and had to record three tracks as recompense over his use of "Here comes old flat-top",
That one always frosted me when Chuck Berry's camp sued John over that. Especially when Berry was a bit of a nicker himself - how do you think Carl Perkins felt when he heard the line "don't you step on my blue suede shoes" in Berry's 'Roll Over Beethoven'. It happens tons. To say it's a shame and a blot on George's reputation, is a bit over the top. If that was really the case, then consider most composers shamed and blotted.
The following people thank Zig for this post:Bulldog
17 October 2013
You'll not hear me defend any pinchers on what they pinched. John and Dylan and 100's more included. I still like George. Just a case of recognizing the fact and moving on.
'My Sweet Lord" remains a great song. Not many big hits have you waiting for a couple of minutes, whatever it is, for the drums to come in.
The following people thank Atlas for this post:Zig
Most Users Ever Online: 597
Currently Online: Zig, meanmistermustard, AppleScruffJunior, Mr Bellamy, Ahhh Girl, Annadog40, Merch, HongKongLady, Lend27
Currently Browsing this Page:
Ahhh Girl: 7253
mr. Sun king coming together: 6931
Mr. Kite: 5575
Ron Nasty: 3684
Guest Posters: 88
Newest Members: Lend27, ednew, josekelly637, yardengruman, Harrisons Guitar Makes Me Weep
Moderators: Ahhh Girl: 7253, meanmistermustard: 12303, Zig: 5439, Joe: 3883
Administrators: Joe: 3883, Ellie: 1