Forty-three years after John Lennon sensationally claimed that The Beatles were 'more popular than Jesus', it finally came to pass.
For seven days in September, amid the hubbub surrounding the remastered CDs and the Rock Band game, The Beatles finally overtook Jesus as a search term, according to Google Trends.
Lennon made his controversial claim in a March 1966 interview given to Maureen Cleave and first published in the Evening Standard newspaper. When his words were republished by Datebook magazine four months later it caused a storm of negative publicity, culminating in public bonfires of The Beatles' records and a public backlash that at times made the group fearful for their lives.
Christianity will go. It will vanish and shrink. I needn't argue about that; I'm right and I will be proved right. We're more popular than Jesus now; I don't know which will go first - rock 'n' roll or Christianity. Jesus was all right but his disciples were thick and ordinary. It's them twisting it that ruins it for me.
The protests were mainly in the southern US states. Lennon eventually issued an apology, and was reportedly shaken by the backlash.
I wasn't saying whatever they're saying I was saying. I'm sorry I said it really. I never meant it to be a lousy anti-religious thing. I apologise if that will make you happy. I still don't know quite what I've done. I've tried to tell you what I did do but if you want me to apologise, if that will make you happy, then OK, I'm sorry.
The devil may have the best tunes, but Jesus was back on top of the stats just a few days later.
In England, people were staying away from church by the droves. John was right about his observation.
It's always been an embarrassment to me that so-called Christians did so many ridiculous things rather than just do what Jesus would have instructed: love them.
It says a lot that the Beatles had to discover "love" someplace else.
Love?
The Beatles sang "All You Need Is Love" and then they broke up...
Human emotional love don't cut it.
Jesus didnt speak of that kind of love, only the True, "Agape" Love that only God can make grow inside a persons heart.
What has the message contained in "All You Need Is Love" got to do with the Beatles being together or breaking up?
The message is still valid.
"Human emotional love don't cut it".
If we are not human than what are we? Creatures from Avatar?
If it wasn't for human emotional love none of us would be here.
7 days vs 2000 years!!! I think Jesus wins this one!
Hey Steven--Jesus was all right, but his disciples (and some of his followers) were thick and ordinary.
Yes, "Ordinary", just like you and the rest of us Joe's.
All those who think they are better than someone else, are no better than the worst of us.
Jesus ran into those kind of folks all the time.
They thought they were better than those others too.
How do you know? Were you there?
John Lennon was really kind and gracious to call Jesus Christ, The Son of GOD, "ALRIGHT". Bit of an understatement...
I can't imagine the world of hurt that Mister Lennon just might be experiencing at this very moment. Lord have mercy!
This has always been a stickler for me in that while my dad was a minister I agreed with Lennon. Lennon never said the Beatles were more important than Jesus or Christianity, just more popular, and popularity is an entirely different issue. All you have to do is look at things like concerts. Paul McCartney can charge $500 for a concert ticket, but even in his heyday, someone like Billy Graham could never, if he chose to, charge an equivalent figure. If I needed the key to Heaven, I would consult Graham first, but if I needed to win an popularity contest, I would call McCartney. Totally different concept.
The Beatles sold love and peace. Billy Graham sold the Lord like a commodity. If needed the key to heaven id much rather get it from the fabs rather then some scum who thinks that religion is his to profit from.
Reading about how in the southern US there were protests is rather sad.
The Beatles promoted unconditional love, Jesus did that. While many many of those so-called christians that pray every day hate and despise their fellow black brothers...
So instead of protesting those people should have thought about whose way of living would have more appaled to Jesus.
yup, Steven is right, if you integrate the area under the Google curves, Jesus surely wins. Agree with Mike too, though. And John's "disciples runing it" comment is right.
Just the thought of people comparing The Beatles to Jesus at this point of time
makes me sick, how can anyone compare the creations with the creator???
However, Jesus wouldn't ever waste time with popularity here on earth, where
nobody wants to hear a word he said and just wants to do whatever they please
no matter about anything at all. Luke 11:23a
Quoting John Lennon: "The Beatles were just a great band, that's all...", I
agree with him, I grew up listening to them, I've musically learned and have
been influenced a lot by them and I'm thankful for their legacy, still think
it would be nice to shake Paul McCartney's hand.
"They're still the 20th Century's Greatest Romance".
Well, so far nobody's killed in the name of the Beatles (Charles Manson doesn't count), so to me, they are bigger than Jesus. They've left of legacy of peace, love and happiness without causing thousands of deaths.
Bang on!
Why does Charles Manson not count?
Yeah, Manson definitely counts. As does, perversely enough, Mark David Chapman. Which isn't to say they're to "blame", any more than Jesus or Mohammad or whoever. Causation is not culpability.
No They Don't. They were sick, mentally unstable people who killed people due to their mental inbalance.
Yes, they were. And if the Beatles had never existed, maybe Manson and his killing rampage would've been inspired by the Rolling Stones' "Let It Bleed" instead of the white album; likewise, John Lennon would be just an average citizen and the deranged Chapman would've gone after Todd Rundgren instead. And that wouldn't mean that the Stones or Rundgren would be anymore "to blame" for such atrocities than the Beatles - it just makes them the inadvertent inspiration. That's all I meant.
Well, Okay Then. I Just hate all that Manson Killed people because the Beatles said to
al the beatles songs were about love and be loved ...big J would have been a Beatles fan!
OK - so I'm doing a lot of this from memory - but I believe John's comments were about the state of things in England - he began his quote saying something like "Christianity will fade . . ." - and for awhile his comments were accurate - Christianity in England did fade - although my understanding that it has been growing again - more through the modern churches than the Church of England.
In terms of the rest of the world, John wasn't commenting on the state of religion internationally, so his comments were totally misconstrued in the US.
However, given the religious climate in the US during the 60's it's not surprising things got so out of hand.
John's comments about Jesus' followers (thick and ordinary) were, in my opinion, the typical unfiltered comments of a 25 year old at almost any moment in time.
The full interview containing Lennon's remarks can be read here.